Quoting: TopCornerShot
Spooner's averaged 44 points the last 2 years and Pominville has averaged 42. Spooner shoots a higher % and is better on the PP than Pominville. Yes, Spooner is terrible at wing and has no intensity to his game, but they can work around that easily. They can just play Spooner at C, but have someone else take the face-off. Spooner will be better in any other teams system than Boston when it comes to playing defense. Boston has put one of the biggest priorities on defense that there is across the league. The grand savings in a deal of Spooner for Pominville is more than double what you're saving them by giving them McQuaid instead of Scandella, which makes it far more logical. If they really want to save money while at the same time downgrading less then they should only consider a Spooner / Pominville swap. You talk about McQuaid's toughness like he's a good hitter, which he really isn't. He's just a good fighter which is barely even beneficial anymore. To add insult to injury you called Ryan Spooner too much money for the Wild to afford, when in reality theres a 99% chance he gets less than the 2.75M McQuaid makes.
Having no intensity isn't an easy work around.
The Wild's solution to Spooner sucking at FO would be to send Koivu to take the FO. Same way Bos sends Bergeron out for every possible FO. The wing that would be taking FOs on the 3rd line would be Pommer.
Spooner won't see the PP for on the Wild. Granlund/Koivu/Nino and Parise/Staal/Coyle are the normal FWD groups. Spooner doesn't beat out any of those players. The only reason Pommer gets any PP time is he plays the point position and that's sporadically.
3C on the Wild is expected to play on the PK, not winning FO's and not good defensively isn't a of much use.
Wild have JEE slated to play 3C to start the season, Coyle is also an option.
Center position (d-zone) for the Wild plays around the top of the crease, helps clear the crease, and covers for whatever d-man is pursuing a puck carrier. It's one of the things that makes Spurgeon effective, he's free to float around. None of those things are Spooner's strong suits. It's one of the reason's Granlund couldn't make it as a center in the Wild.
Wild need center depth, for sure. But Spooner isn't really a good option as a 3C, and not an option at all as a wing. I really don't see him getting less the $2.75m a year 49p and 39p seasons are worth money. He's a really bad fit on the Wild team.