| ROUND 1 | TEAM | ORIGINAL | PLAYER | DETAILS |
|---|
| 1 | - | Johnathan Toews | was a toss up with Clarke. Sent Toews home as a tie breaker | |
| 2 | - | Bobby Clarke | ||
| 3 | - | Terry Sawchuck | ||
| 4 | - | Duncan Keith | ||
| 5 | - | Ed Belfour | ||
| 6 | - | Andy Bathgate | ||
| 7 | - | Mark Stone | ||
| 8 | - | Butch Goring | ||
| 9 | - | James Patrick | ||
| 10 | - | Mike Ridley | ||
| 11 | - | Alexander Steen | ||
| 12 | Patrick Sharp | |||
| 13 | - | Ron Hextall | ||
| 14 | - | Reggie Leach | ||
| 15 | - | Pete Stemkowski | ||
| 16 | - | Travis Zajac | ||
| 17 | James Reimer | |||
| 18 | - | Bill Mosienko | ||
| 19 | Dennis Hextall | |||
| 20 | - | Mike Keane | ||
| 21 | - | Blaine Stoughton | ||
| 22 | Carey Wilson | |||
| 23 | - | Bill Fairbairn | ||
| 24 | Ab McDonald | |||
| 25 | Max Domi | |||
| 26 | Brad Maxwell | |||
| 27 | - | Seth Jarvis | ||
| 28 | Ray Neufeld | |||
| 29 | Connor Geekie | |||
| 30 | - | Dean Evason | ||
| 31 | Ryan Reaves | |||
| 32 | - | Jesse Pollock | Very underrated and should have made the show LOL |