Forums/NHL

In the GM Game V1 who's team is better?

Who has the better overall team?
The chart has been hidden

Poll Options

 

Sep 15, 2017 at 6:16
#1
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Vote!
Sep 15, 2017 at 6:18
#2
rangersandislesfan
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 27,378
Likes: 3,101
In v1 probably the Pens.
Mr_cap liked this.
Sep 15, 2017 at 8:17
#3
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 1,873
Likes: 163
What is this??
Sep 15, 2017 at 8:38
#4
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: PaulDunnill
What is this??


The GM Game
Sep 15, 2017 at 8:50
#5
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 1,873
Likes: 163
Shouldn't it be in the GM Game forum???
Sep 15, 2017 at 9:12
#6
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: PaulDunnill
Shouldn't it be in the GM Game forum???


Nah.. im asking this to everyone on the site cuz we had a little debate to say the least.
Sep 16, 2017 at 12:33
#7
Blues GM v4
Joined: Nov 2016
Posts: 8,287
Likes: 2,565
That is no question. As much as I hate any form of Pittsburgh, that team is lethal
Mr_cap liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 12:44
#8
V4 DET GM
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 7,525
Likes: 2,586
Florida Panthers in 8 years...
plNHL liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 1:05
#9
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: krakowitz
That is no question. As much as I hate any form of Pittsburgh, that team is lethal


Thank you.


Nate Elder where you at?
Sep 16, 2017 at 2:23
#10
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 786
Likes: 473
I was once the AGM of pit for like 12 hours so i gotta represent
Mr_cap and MrBooth liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 7:42
#11
Quebec GM v4
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 9,326
Likes: 2,225
DavidBooth7's Pittsburgh Penguins were better than the Mr_Cap's Pittsburgh Penguins.
Rodzikhockey93, Pasta88Sauce, jmac490 and 1 other person liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 9:23
#12
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: phillyjabroni
DavidBooth7's Pittsburgh Penguins were better than the Mr_Cap's Pittsburgh Penguins.


No they were not. Stop sucking up to him.
Sep 16, 2017 at 10:41
#13
Quebec GM v4
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 9,326
Likes: 2,225
Quoting: Mr_cap
Quoting: phillyjabroni
DavidBooth7's Pittsburgh Penguins were better than the Mr_Cap's Pittsburgh Penguins.


No they were not. Stop sucking up to him.


Drouin - Crosby - Simmonds
Kreider - Backstrom (50%) - Pavelski
Danault - Kesler - Vrbata
Beartschi - Pageau - Rust

OEL - Burns (5.25M)
Krug - Weber (50%)
Weber - Ellis

Talbot - Dell

Saad - Crosby - Simmonds
Drouin - Backstrom (50%) - Anderson, Josh
Caggiula - Kadri - Hayden
Clifford - Pageau - Vrbata

OEL - Larsson
Werenski - Hamonic
Krug - Johns

Talbot - Dell
Pasta88Sauce and MrBooth liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 11:44
#14
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: phillyjabroni
Quoting: Mr_cap


No they were not. Stop sucking up to him.


Drouin - Crosby - Simmonds
Kreider - Backstrom (50%) - Pavelski
Danault - Kesler - Vrbata
Beartschi - Pageau - Rust

OEL - Burns (5.25M)
Krug - Weber (50%)
Weber - Ellis

Talbot - Dell

Saad - Crosby - Simmonds
Drouin - Backstrom (50%) - Anderson, Josh
Caggiula - Kadri - Hayden
Clifford - Pageau - Vrbata

OEL - Larsson
Werenski - Hamonic
Krug - Johns

Talbot - Dell


So lets break it down..

The first line stays the same if Drouin moves up. Cancel that.

Saad is better than Kreider. And Pav is better than Anderson. Backstrom is the C. This stays even.

Drake and Dan lets say are even. Kadri is better than Kesler. Lets cancel Vrbata out.

Cliff and Bart. I would give the edge to Cliff. Cancel Pag out. Hayden is better than Rust.

Overall, for forwards, its pretty even but I have better depth.

On defense, OEL cancels each other out. Burns obvi better than Larsson. Krug cancels each other out. Werenski and Y. Weber? Lmao. Shea Weber is slow as sh*t and Hamonic did not play well last year. He'll be much better this year with a much much much better team. Thats even. Ellis and Johns, obvi Ellis.

**Remember that Ellis and Kesler are now injured so they wouldnt even be in the lineup**

I wouldnt have traded Ellis had he not been gone for 6 months. With him in my lineup, I would have the overall depth, he would have star power because of Burns and Weber. Take Ellis out of his lineup and my D corpse is better.

In net, its the same.


So tell me exactly how his team is better? The only real diff is Pavelski and Burns. My team is faster, younger, and more overall depth on the wings.
Sep 16, 2017 at 12:38
#15
mhockey91
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 8,570
Likes: 2,531
Quoting: phillyjabroni
Quoting: Mr_cap


No they were not. Stop sucking up to him.


Drouin - Crosby - Simmonds
Kreider - Backstrom (50%) - Pavelski
Danault - Kesler - Vrbata
Beartschi - Pageau - Rust

OEL - Burns (5.25M)
Krug - Weber (50%)
Weber - Ellis

Talbot - Dell

Saad - Crosby - Simmonds
Drouin - Backstrom (50%) - Anderson, Josh
Caggiula - Kadri - Hayden
Clifford - Pageau - Vrbata

OEL - Larsson
Werenski - Hamonic
Krug - Johns

Talbot - Dell


Agreed. Sorry cap Sticking Out Tongue
MrBooth liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 12:39
#16
mhockey91
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 8,570
Likes: 2,531
Still pens are wayyyy better than Edmonton though. Still stacked despite some questionable trades from cap wink
Sep 16, 2017 at 12:47
#17
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: mhockey91
Still pens are wayyyy better than Edmonton though. Still stacked despite some questionable trades from cap wink


What r the questionable trades Mr. Drunk lol


Plus my future is muccch better than booths
Sep 16, 2017 at 12:53
#18
Quebec GM v4
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 9,326
Likes: 2,225
Travis Hamonic's hasn't played well for the last 3 years, per Micah Blake McCurdy, a very respected advanced analytics within the hockey community.

My contention is based on what team I want to deploy if I had to bet my life on a game. At the time of DavidBooth's GMing, Ryan Ellis was damn well a top-25 defensemen in the NHL. You never had to trade Ryan Ellis and simply because you did, doesn't serve any relevancy as to which team is better. Comping the team DavidBooth had compared to yours.

The difference between Josh Anderson and Joe Pavelski is not negated or offset by the difference in Chris Kreider and Brandon Saad. DavidBooth gets the advantage there.

Danualt is vastly better than Drake Caggigula, especially if we are basing it off of last season. He had 40 points, compared to 18.

Sven had 18 goals, Clifford had 12 points...; advantage goes to Sven.

OEL and Krug cancel out. So we are left with:

Werenski + Adam Larsson + Travis Hamonic + Stephen Johns vs. Brent Burns + Shea Weber + Ryan Ellis + Yannick Weber
Burns >> Larsson
Weber >> Hamonic
Ellis >>> Johns
Y. Weber <<<< Werenski

The advantage is DavidBooth's defense.
MrBooth liked this.
Sep 16, 2017 at 1:09
#19
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: phillyjabroni
Travis Hamonic's hasn't played well for the last 3 years, per Micah Blake McCurdy, a very respected advanced analytics within the hockey community.

My contention is based on what team I want to deploy if I had to bet my life on a game. At the time of DavidBooth's GMing, Ryan Ellis was damn well a top-25 defensemen in the NHL. You never had to trade Ryan Ellis and simply because you did, doesn't serve any relevancy as to which team is better. Comping the team DavidBooth had compared to yours.

The difference between Josh Anderson and Joe Pavelski is not negated or offset by the difference in Chris Kreider and Brandon Saad. DavidBooth gets the advantage there.

Danualt is vastly better than Drake Caggigula, especially if we are basing it off of last season. He had 40 points, compared to 18.

Sven had 18 goals, Clifford had 12 points...; advantage goes to Sven.

OEL and Krug cancel out. So we are left with:

Werenski + Adam Larsson + Travis Hamonic + Stephen Johns vs. Brent Burns + Shea Weber + Ryan Ellis + Yannick Weber
Burns >> Larsson
Weber >> Hamonic
Ellis >>> Johns
Y. Weber <<<< Werenski

The advantage is DavidBooth's defense.


Theres plenty of other people in this world other than that guy that you can get an opinion from.

Saad doesnt offset Pav.. but he is damn sure better than Kreider. Anderson can hold his own. Im not even talking about offsetting anyone, but just comparing player to player. There is no advantage there at all. Heck, Drouin with Backstrom would be so skilled and dominant.

Why are you comparing Danaults goals to Drakes and same for Sven and Kyle? Thats ignorant. First off, Danault played a lot on the first line, with Patchy and Radulov. Drake had some stints with McDavid too but played mostly on he bottom line. Drake and Kyle arent there to put up points. They are there to shutdown the other teams line. Which Drake is turning into a capable shutdown player. Clifford can roughen stuff up. Again, Svens job is to score, thats not Cliffs role. Even at that, he had 6 less goals than him. Advantage me.

Agree with Burns tips the scale over for defense on his side, Weber is so slow there isnt an advantage. Between him and Hamonic, its tied. Lets compare Werenski and Ellis... Ellis played good all year just brokeout in the playoffs. Werenski was very dominant as a rookie all year and esp.. in the playoffs. Johns is better than Y. Weber making my defense have more depth.

On defense Id give it to Booth only because Burns. Depth wise, without a doubt its me.
Sep 17, 2017 at 11:08
#20
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 1,873
Likes: 163
Gm Game comments should be in another forum
Sep 18, 2017 at 12:23
#21
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: PaulDunnill
Gm Game comments should be in another forum


I just brought it here cuz we had an argument over which team is better. I think the decision has been made wink
Sep 18, 2017 at 12:24
#22
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 1,873
Likes: 163
Quoting: Mr_cap
Quoting: PaulDunnill
Gm Game comments should be in another forum


I just brought it here cuz we had an argument over which team is better. I think the decision has been made wink


They are all "fantasy" teams so here is no reality to them
Sep 18, 2017 at 12:30
#23
Thread Starter
NBABound
Joined: Oct 2016
Posts: 5,644
Likes: 1,358
Quoting: PaulDunnill
Quoting: Mr_cap


I just brought it here cuz we had an argument over which team is better. I think the decision has been made wink


They are all "fantasy" teams so here is no reality to them


But I have made my team better than his.
Sep 18, 2017 at 3:35
#24
Joined: May 2016
Posts: 5,211
Likes: 1,583
Quoting: Mr_cap
Quoting: PaulDunnill


They are all "fantasy" teams so here is no reality to them


But I have made my team better than his.
\

Paul is the wrong person to be talking to about this lol. He's made it very clear his disdain for fantasy type stuff. Just walk away now before the thread turns into a massive bating/flamming fest where CF gets flooded with reported post because things get out of hand.
Daryl, DoctorBreakfast and Duster liked this.
Sep 18, 2017 at 3:56
#25
V4 DET GM
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 7,525
Likes: 2,586
Quoting: ON3M4N
Quoting: Mr_cap


But I have made my team better than his.
\

Paul is the wrong person to be talking to about this lol. He's made it very clear his disdain for fantasy type stuff. Just walk away now before the thread turns into a massive bating/flamming fest where CF gets flooded with reported post because things get out of hand.


If that's the case, he shouldnt even come to this thread.
phillyjabroni liked this.
 
Reply
To create a post please Login or Register
Question:
Options:
Submit Poll Edit