Subbanator7667

Subbanator

Member Since

Jul 5, 2017

Forum Posts

1234

Posts per Day

2.32

Forum Threads

POSTS

THREADS

LIKES

ARMCHAIR-GM TEAMS

Forum: Armchair-GMMon at 6:19 pm

Thread: Tarasenko

This would depend on when it's done. If Carolina does this and it doesn't fix anything then your giving up what's probably a top 10 pick, that's when the value goes either way. Plus Tarasenko hasnt exactly looked like the next generation of goal scorer everyone thought he was about to turn into so teams betting this much in him may hesitate

Forum: Armchair-GMMon at 2:54 pm

Thread: gotta try

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>thilk</b></div><div>Quick by himself gets a return of a high end prospect, a roster player, and a high pick and thats not even counting that they get toffoli and forbort and dump darlings contract</div></div>

No one is going to trade 10 years of an elite player for what is probably going to be 2 years of Quick. It's not how the league works anymore, especially with his injuries now piling up. LA fans aren't going to like the return from most of their veteran pieces, Quick, Carter and Brown won't bring in the haul fans will want.

Forum: Armchair-GMMon at 1:12 pm

Thread: Maybe

Not a fan of giving up Brooks this early. If he turns out to be another Subban montreal look like idiots.

Noooooo way Ottawa trades Chabot. He is a future Norris candidate and would only be moved if it was a ridiculous haul of elite picks and prospects

Forum: Armchair-GMMon at 10:39 am

Thread: Domi Drouin

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>JayBeagleFanAccount</b></div><div>a lot better</div></div>

Their also older and more expensive. I agree their better, Tarasenko will probably always be the better goal scorer but I wouldn't doubt that Domi and Drouin become better then Orielly before the end of their careers

Forum: Armchair-GMMon at 10:36 am

Thread: Leafs Trades with Blues and Flyers

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Jamiepo</b></div><div>People who say things like this are always surprised when an actual trade happens. The values just aren’t shat you think.</div></div>

Not really, look at what they got for a rental Shattenkirk a couple years ago, two prospects, a first, and two conditional picks. Shattenkirk wasn't as good as Petro, he had less time on his contract and he wasnt being sent with a top prospect.

I just think that if they move Petro other teams would easily be able give them a better package. Liligren is the most attractive piece of that trade but he is still a prospect who is looking like he is gonna be a 4-5 dman.

Blues will be looking for quality not quantity. So they would be looking for an A prospect, a first and a decent roster player. Now I am saying this without knowing what's going on with his injury, that could change things.

Forum: Armchair-GMSun at 6:10 pm

Thread: gotta try

Even your reasoning for the Carolina isn't good enough. LA is going to get a decent return for Quick but it's not a #2 overall pick, a top 4 dman, and high end picks

Forum: Armchair-GMSun at 6:07 pm

Thread: Leafs Trades with Blues and Flyers

St Louis says no in an instant. It is good to know that Leaf fans think they can get a top pairing defenceman without giving up anything of significant value

Forum: Armchair-GMSun at 3:39 pm

Thread: BYEBYE PARAYKO AND BOZAK-TRADES WITH TORONTO AND CAROLINA

Did you make these trades in NHL 19 and think they were realistic?

If the Blues trade Parayko it's for an elite piece or a top pick at the draft.

Forum: Armchair-GMSun at 3:36 pm

Thread: Helping the Flyers Sabres and Leafs

Simply put, to many pieces. No real elite pieces coming back and every trade is basically an NHL 19 trade.

Price and Weber are retiring Habs unless some unreal trade gets handed to them which won't happen.

Forum: Armchair-GMSun at 3:32 pm

Thread: Rebuild

Dont think you get that for Anisimov. Chicago was asking for 2 second rounders in the summer apparently and no team was willing to do that, so doubt they get that package. Would see getting a second pick and prospect but not 4 pieces

Forum: Armchair-GMSun at 3:22 pm

Thread: TEAM CANADA

I think that these teams always depend on where the tournament takes place, if it's a European ice surface you're probably going to see a more skating oriented team going. If it's in NA you probably see a bit of a older team that plays by the system

Forum: Armchair-GMSat at 3:29 pm

Thread: Cup team

Honestly dont get how Kapanens value is that of a high end winger. I know he is good but he is playing in the best offense in the league and benefiting from being the guy who isn't keyed in on against.

Pietrangelo has been a top 20 dman in this league for years now and is a proven top pairing player, that package won't get him and Leafs fans need to calm down on the value of their players

Forum: Armchair-GMSat at 12:49 pm

Thread: Realistic Tarasenko and Pietrangelo trade

I think the Leafs should use their players inflated values to make trades. Kapanen is on pace for almost 60 points, out him on any other team though and he is a 30 point player.

And Liligren is a good prospect but looks to be a 4-5 guy in the NHL, Zaitzev is NHL capable but his salary is detrimental. Finally the pick is probably going to be between #25-32 so it has a 60% of making the NHL club.

If you can get a top 20 dman in the league for that package I would day do it. Pietro is hurt so I think that rules him out but might as well capitalize on young players reputations

Forum: Armchair-GMFri at 5:10 pm

Thread: Habs more youth trades car-tor

Your not getting Slavin for that package, I agree with the one guy on here, Slavin is one of the best in the league, very underrated because of where he plays but when it comes to the defensive zone their are few better then him and none are as young.

Also dont think Kapanen is worth Petry straight up. This is his first season and has been playing on an elite offense and his numbers have shown as much. Petry is a tried and tested top 4 dman who can handle top pairing minutes, Toronto would have to add to that deal.

Forum: Armchair-GMThu at 9:53 am

Thread: Stanley hère We come

Horrible deal for MTL and Stanley would be going far away from MTL

Forum: Armchair-GMWed at 7:32 pm

Thread: Jake Gardiner

I think the value is there just because the pick is likely to be between 12-20 which is typically what a 50 point dman being moved would fetch. But neither team does this deal, Toronto wants to make a run for a cup and they tend to keep players as their own rentals. Montreal wouldn't do it because why give up assets just to sign a guy in the off season (actually dont think they stand a chance at getting him)

Forum: Armchair-GMDec 12 at 8:27

Thread: Defensemen

Life isn't NHL 19

Forum: Armchair-GMDec 11 at 6:40

Thread: Best top 6 in the NHL

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>mk458</b></div><div>Since PLD was already taken at 3rd, Montreal wouldn't have been interested. And that wouldn't have been enough anyways. Rumors were the 4th OA and Hall, or Draisaitl and the 4th overall.</div></div>

That was the demand apparently, Draisaitle and 4th overall for Subban and Edmonton said no.

Forum: Armchair-GMDec 11 at 5:03

Thread: parayko baby

The team that's gets the best player in a trade wins the trade, Toronto wins this trade. Parayko would instantly become their top pair dman and they wouldn't have to give up an elite asset, they take that deal.

Forum: Armchair-GMDec 11 at 1:26

Thread: Next Year

I dont think Poehling and Brook will be ready for the NHL next year, probably play a few games but most likely spend the majority of the year in Laval.

12 3 Last

Page 1 of 62

ARCHIVE

CBA

PLAYERS

EASTERN CONFERENCE

WESTERN CONFERENCE

CALCULATORS