kaljakori

Member Since
Dec 2, 2017
Favourite Team
Toronto Maple Leafs
Location
Tampere, FIN
Forum Posts
446
Posts per Day
0.6
Forum Threads
48
Forum: NHL SigningsAug 6 at 10:28
Forum: NHL SigningsJun 19 at 1:57
Forum: NHL SigningsMay 24 at 4:34
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>pharrow</b></div><div>I have already commented on this and you seem to ignore that part.
He's a UFA, Nylander was a RFA, Nylander also got 1 million per year more.
Those are big factors in this discussion. Fact is, nothing in Nylanders career so far screams he will be a consistent player over 20 some goals. The fact that he is surrounded with a lot more talent helps with those assist numbers.
So as I was saying. It's a decent comparable when you are talking about 20 goal scoring players. Which is exactly what Nylander has been so far.</div></div>

<strong>"He's a UFA, Nylander was a RFA"</strong>

Have you not noticed that RFA's have been getting as much (or more) than comparable UFA's for the past two years?

RFA's are getting higher cap-hits (on long-term contracts) to account for potential improvement (Draisaitl, Eichel, Matthews, etc)
UFA's are getting lower cap-hits (on long-term contracts) to account for their potential decline (Ellis, McDonagh, Wheeler, etc)

The two highest cap-hits in the league were given to 21 year old RFA's .... the UFA argument doesn't really apply anymore.

<strong>"Nylander also got 1 million per year more"</strong>

Nylander's cap-hit is <strong>15%</strong> higher than Nelsons.
He produced <strong>40%</strong> more offense than Nelson (in the 2 years prior to their signings).
He did this in his rookie + sophomore seasons while being six years younger than Nelson.

<strong>"Fact is, nothing in Nylanders career so far screams he will be a consistent player over 20 some goals"</strong>

Nylanders 1st NHL season = <strong>22 </strong>goals / <strong>61 </strong>points
Nylanders 2nd NHL season = <strong>20 </strong>goals / <strong>61 </strong>points

Then he signed his contract .... that about as consistent as a 20 to 21 year old player could possible be LMAO.
Nelson was in the AHL at 20 and a 4th line player at 21 ... then he improved drastically over the next 6 years.
Yet somehow you think Nylander's career peaked when he was a rookie?

<strong>"The fact that he is surrounded with a lot more talent helps with those assist numbers"</strong>

Nylander has played with Brown, Marleau and Hyman as much as he's played with Matthews.
Nelson also gets more ice-time than Nylander ... and I think he was on one of the highest scoring teams in the NHL last year?

<strong>"It's a decent comparable when you are talking about 20 goal scoring players. Which is exactly what Nylander has been so far".</strong>

Lets just ignore the fact that Nylander is a <strong>much </strong> better playmaker ... which is his primary offensive skill set.
Lets also ignore the fact that Nelson is not a good playmaker .... so goal scoring is his primary offensive skill set.

Even if we ignore both of the facts ... this is still a horrible comparison LMAO.
If you want to compare players you have to compare them at the same point in their career.

When they were both at the exact same point in their career as Nylander's signing ... they were exactly this:

Nelson = <strong>14 </strong>goal and <strong>26 </strong>point scorer (proven for 1 season)
Nylander = <strong>21 </strong>goal and <strong>61 </strong>point scorer (proven over 2 seasons)

That is exactly what they had both proven at the same age.

We now know that Nelsons ceiling is as a 20 goal / 50 point player ....
And that is probably Nylander's absolute floor ...
And he has the potential to double those numbers during his contract.
Forum: NHL SigningsMay 24 at 2:11
Forum: Armchair-GMApr 29 at 9:35