Member Since
Jun 27, 2019
Favourite Team
Toronto Maple Leafs
2nd Favourite Team
San Jose Sharks
The Hammer
Forum Posts
Posts per Day
Forum Threads
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 18 at 7:22
Thread: 2020-21 RFAs
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>OldNYIfan</b></div><div>I think Ryu is in the sweet spot of his career. He's been around long enough to have learned that real long-term success at pitching requires out-thinking the batters and therefore acquiring the skills necessary to win (i.e., a sufficient inventory of pitches and knowing when to use each one). When you're young and can blow hitters away, all you need is that fastball and one type of breaking ball, but once you're no longer able to overpower hitters with pure speed, you need more than two pitches. I think you'll be happy with Ryu for at least a couple of years.</div></div>

I couldn't agree more! I think he was the smart play for us in terms of bang for your buck and the fact that he didn't have a QO attached to him. Cole would have likely cost us $400-420mill on a 10-12 year deal and that's IF he would have even considered us, Strausberg I wouldn't touch with his injury history and again what it would have cost (we have to overpay to get most to consider coming here) and Odorizzi accepted his QO so that took us out of that convo.

Wheeler made sense but with having to forfeit the 45th oa pick and international bonus pool money it wasn't worth it (plus I like Ryu more). I think our FO got it right with ryu and I think Roark is getting overlooked by a lot of people. I don't expect him to be something he's not but after going through 21 different starters (I know the opener strategy played a large part in that) he can give us consistent a bite unspectacular results and being able to rely on him to pitch every 5th day will go along way to helping stabilize our rotation IMO.

Would you say our off-season has been a success or failure so far?

Edit: I just saw we signed Panik and Dull to minor league deals. I'm kinda in shock Panik chose to come here but if he makes our roster he'll earn $2.85 so it's likely more than other teams would be willing to offer.

Thanks for the input it's much appreciated! 👍
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 18 at 6:16
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 18 at 5:19
Thread: 2020-21 RFAs
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>OldNYIfan</b></div><div>In a perfect world, this would be true justice.

You'll get as old as I am waiting for it to happen.

I'll even improve on your idea: instead of a blanket ban for one year, which wouldn't hurt them if they don't make the playoffs, what about a ban <strong>the next time the team qualifies for the playoffs</strong>?

Bet you'd only have to impose that ban once.</div></div>

That's what I'm talking about!

My idea was anyone caught cheating (players) would hurt their future financial earnings, let's use Springer as an example... Let's say the Astros get a 1year ban from the playoffs like the 1-year bans for Himch and Lunow or a 2year ban like the draft picks lost or a 3-year ban because they've been cheating for 3 years (probably longer but you get my point), in Springers case a 1-year ban doesn't hurt him as much but a 2-year or 3-year ban and any team looking at him in GA next year would be hesitant to sign him because he wouldn't be eligible for the playoffs and in this case would have lost his arb rights for this year (likely carrying the same AAV as last year or potentially less, IMO, that would deter players from cheating in the future and owners would make sure that their team isn't cheating because they forfeit their picks in those years.

Also, that's why want to see the amount a team (owner) can be fined to $50 mill <a href="/users/oneX" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">@oneX</a> is right it may not be that much to Crane but how many owners can afford to pay that? Look at the Rays payroll last year or Oakland or Cleveland etc. Those owners couldn't afford a fine that big so they would be more careful who they hire and would monitor their teams more closely. IMO, the punishment should be viewed more as a deterrent for other teams going forward because the punishment will only get worse the more team's get caught. Another thing Manfred could do is fine players who are already under contract like Altuve for example.

From a neutral party, what do you think of the Blue Jay's off-season so far? And can you give me more insight into what to expect from Ryu going forward? I know he doesn't have overpowering stuff but he's effective and he has a good pitching arsenal also I expect him to not be as effective coming to the AL East but he should be the best pitcher for us next year.
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 18 at 4:59
Thread: 2020-21 RFAs
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 18 at 4:49
Thread: 2020-21 RFAs
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Trickster</b></div><div>More then being speculated.
It is just the way it is.

I want the hammer dropped on the players too.</div></div>

<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>OldNYIfan</b></div><div>Here are two simple adjustments:

1. Baseball is, more than any other major sport, statistics-intensive. Therefore, any batting statistic for a Houston player relating to the third, fourth and fifth game of the World Series should have an asterisk attached to it.

2. Houston gets no home games for the next two post-seasons; let them play on a neutral field of a non-playoff team (or teams, could rotate) so that those fans could get to see post-season games.</div></div>

Okay, but if it means that players wouldn't come forward in the future would you still want them punished?

Also, a question for both of you and <a href="/users/oneX" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">@oneX</a> what do you guys think of banning the Astros from postseason play? Hear me out on this one, by banning them from the playoffs all incentive to cheat would be gone IMO. The players want to win so they would be deterred managers and coaching staff are already deterred from cheating after the 1-year bans handed out and gm's wouldn't want to cheat either for the same reasons. Also, if a player is set to hit FA the acquiring team would not have their services for the postseason until the ban is over. If a player is arb eligible they could lose those rights as well, IMO, that would get rid of cheating in the game.

In this case, you could band them for either 1,2 or 3 years and the penalties only become more severe each time a team gets caught. You may not like it but I think it would be effective.... I mean, would you cheat if that was the punishment? And it punishes the players like you guys want. I'm guessing I'll get a thumbs down on this one, oh well just an idea.
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 16 at 10:34
Thread: 2020-21 RFAs
Forum: Armchair-GMJan 14 at 9:14
Thread: 2020-21 RFAs
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>OldNYIfan</b></div><div>You bet! However, it's not clear to me what punishment is actually available here. I would think that the least that could be done is vacate the two World Series wins against the Dodgers. But then I sound like a whining homer.

When I was in high school, the Angels were formed and my granduncle immediately got season tickets, so when I would come out here from NY in the summer I would go to a lot of those games. I remember the one glory year of Dean Chance and Bo Belinsky pretty well. Well, no I don't -- the Sixties intervened -- but you get the picture.</div></div>

What would you have liked to see done? I wanted Crane to get a $50mill fine but I get the max amount is $5 mill.... I just think that's a joke of a fine and I wanted to see 3 first's but am fine with the 2 1sts and 2nds.

You don't sound like a whining homer me <a href="/users/Trickster" target="_blank">@Trickster</a> and <a href="/users/oneX" target="_blank">@oneX</a> are Jay's fans and are pretty pissed about this whole situation.... I can only imagine how the Dodgers organization and fans are taking this.

It musta been pretty fun to watch them from their inaugural season! Lots of great year's but for the last 5-6 years I can't help but think how far they could go if they'd just go and get a couple of Aces. I know you guys got Otani but man this team shoots itself in the foot every off-season although it should be fun to see what Madden can do with this team. Say any chance you would be interested in trading us that bum in center know that fish guy... Lol... Don't worry I'll stop lol. A guy can dream right?