Every team declines and its not close

Lol, no, McTavish is untouchable, and Gibson's agent put out a statement about how he has zero desire to play in Toronto.

Rental market with trade protection doesn't have that kind of value anyway unless he comes with a sub 9 million 8 year extension

Every marner trade on here is a Leafs fan calling marner a name and then trading him for the most untouchable piece imaginable

I wonder who wants this deal less Verbeek or Gibson

MacT is more valuable than Marner so tell your friends to stop

Who would actually want to trade for Gibson? Bad (& still declining) goalie on a terrible contract; love McTavish (no chance Ducks move him) but if any trade that involves Gibson going to Leafs is awful 🤦🏻

MacT at the moment is not as good as Marner but still great provides and thus on paper the trade is on value for a projected yearly 100 points player. But on paper is where it ends. MacT is a leader and younger and showing year after year great improvement and quite possible could be an even player than Marner. Even if he doesn't his style of play is way different and all teams would benefited for a player like MacT. Thus as many said. MacT is fully untouchable by the ducks.

On the leafs side, Gibsons play has been slowly deteriorating. He is not the same as he was. This using him as a starter could very well be a repeat of Sammy. He will have his good and his bad weeks of play. Because of Wolls injury history we need a much more consistent 1b-1a goalie. So leafs have no need for Gibson. Add in that Gibson may not still want to go to Toronto proves a big no go by players and/or management by such a trade.

OTT would probably do this trade.

Liljegren isn't by any means an upgrade to Chychrun but I'm sure the Sens would use the pick as collateral to flip it and grab another body.

OTT declines

Even if you removed the 2nd coming from OTT they would still decline this deal.