SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

habitantlecolon

Le patriote
Member Since
Dec. 1, 2018
Favourite Team
Montreal Canadiens
Forum Posts
6412
Posts per Day
3.2
Forum: Armchair-GMSat. at 8:03 a.m.
Thread: Oh hell yeah
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Lsendel3</b></div><div>I mean do you disagree? Wahlstrom has very little value. 23 year old still trying to crack the show along with injuries. Smilinac is an ECHL body at 22. Lee just had his worst season at 33, and will turn 34 before the next season. He may hold some value, but the other 2 sure don’t. Please explain if they do, and why a drop of 16 is warranted.</div></div>

if that's the question. 2024 is not the biggest draft. the 16 drop is not that huge and yes Barron still holds value. We didn't demote him (nor was it the case with Xhekaj) we have 11 capable NHL d-men. So we used AHL for Barron to correct his d-zone touches with the puck (mainly head up and pass lines) and his approach as a defender (pace and place where to stand to defend). RHD is a rare thing in the NHL and therefore holds great value. A 23-year-old is not yet a bust, Goalie and Defenders take more time than a forward to develop. He's projected as a top 6 PP specialist with a top 4 upside if he can top all his skills to the limit. If the price is not as you wish we can also add Pittsburgh 2nd 2025 to sweeten the deal, we have seen many times deals with a young player + 3rd round pick to go top 15 (Romanov deal anyone?), so why a half-priced captain for 2 years with playoffs experience + a 23 years rhd wouldn't fetch more? (I'm not asking for a top5 )
Forum: Armchair-GMSat. at 5:06 a.m.
Thread: Oh hell yeah
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>dannibalcorpse</b></div><div>Just confused - why would it cost the Islanders a first to turn Lee/Cizikas/Wahlstrom into Dvorak (worse value than Cizikas) &amp; Justin Barron, but then the Habs can turn around and turn Wahlstrom &amp; Lee (with retention) into a jump from #27OA to #11OA?

Based on your logic, couldn't the Isles just eat the cap on Lee's deal, staple Wahlstrom and #18OA to him, and move up to #8/9OA? Then they'd still have Cizikas instead of Dvorak - I don't think Barron is bad value, but as of now the Isles have Dobson/Pulock/Mayfield under contract on the right side and he doesn't really fit - so I can't see Lamoriello valuing him incredibly highly.</div></div>

Well, why not, If the Islanders fans do not want to retain, Habs are happy to do so and jump up. Lee is not a garbage cap dump.
Forum: Armchair-GMFri. at 9:44 a.m.
Thread: donuts
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>sharcuda22</b></div><div>I mean if we were to get Barron, then we would have almost 10 d guys fighting for the bottom four. Barron isnt good enough to play on top pair so he’s just going to get thrown in the blender. We also have Emberson, Thompson, Laroque and Addison (but i dont think we resign him). Barron just isnt the profile of defender we should continue to add. &amp; At 23 he is still trying to crack the NHL which d-men do take longer but isnt that still about when players start to hit their ceilings generally? I dont see it as a good bet.</div></div>

We put Barron in the minor so he can gain the extra second in the d-zone. He's a great first passer but in a bit of stress sometimes when under pressure. He's a good 200ft two way to become, we just have too much skilled younger d at the moment. He's way better than Addison and can offer you some time to develop your young D crew