Quoting: oilersguy
How is this package yikes ?
I actually do like Carter - and obviously I respect Xavier.
If I’m Grier; I’m actually not upset and this I see as a realistic offer. But I’d try and get more from Edmonton by offering even more retention - Arizona can help (SJS and EDM would pay up; I’ve often used Chmelevski (a guy who needs a change in scenery since he’s in the KHL) and some 4th rounders for a mil or 1.5).
I’d try personally;
EK65 - 7m$$$
Id also throw in any desirable depth roster player. For example I see Lorentz of interest for EDM. Just as nice depth piece who’s been playing well and is a great character for the locker room.
For
Xavier
Broberg
AND CARTER maybe?
2023 first (conditional on EDM passing the first round?)
and offer to take the lesser of EDMs players. If they value Ceci less than Id take Ceci. Or vice versa if it’s still Barrie.
It’s hard to gauge the value of what Grier would accept (I will be in shambles if it’s less than your offer). It’s even harder to gauge the value of Karlsson at 7m.
I’d be looking for Xavier and 2023 first (but I see EDM as a cup winner..), so I see that as a second which is why I’m looking at Broberg. And I’d still ponder how I could get Carter. I see Carter potentially struggling to get into the top 6 in the NHL. So I see a talented smaller worker on the third line but the kids always risen to the challenge of being under appreciated as a 4th rounder. Broberg I honestly still see as grenade. 2nd pair puck mover or bust. But Xavier is the real gem so I’m happy as long as he’s returning. It’s greedy to ask for all 3 but I’d still try it!