Quoting: StuTheSniper
Wow you guys are dumb. You basically just restated my first comment.
Google "sign and trade" and tell me the definition. I don't want no BS about how it translates to any other sport. I want a definition of a SIGN AND TRADE.
So okay, as previously conceded, in the NBA's CBA, they gave this specific type of deal a name, that name being a "sign-and-trade." I will conced you are correct that to be an official sign and trade its gotta be NBA, i will give you that.
What I cant give you however is the rest of what youve argued.
1. This hornqvist deal is not an official sign and trade, nor did the OP ever say it is. OP said it would look like one of the many deals that he gave to you as examples
2. you asked for an example of a similar deal EVER happening in the NHL, OP provided a bunch, one of which was EXACT (Hossa)
3. Youre being silly if you think hornqvist is the signing to argue about here...
4. Horny's FA rights are far more valuable than a guy like Jimmy Vesey so no, hes not worth a 7th
5. It is incredibly common to refer to those types of deals as a sign and trade even if they arent in the NBA or exactly the same, sports borrow terms from other sports literally all the time. Hell sportsnet spent all of last season hyping a potential "Steven stamkos sign and trade" and while it neither happened nor would be a real sign and trade by your count, its perfectly normal and okay to use the term.
so there we have it our game is over and sure, you scored a goal but you still lost 5-1man