Pittsburgh have 2 solid goalies in Murray and Jarry, and with the expansion draft coming up next summer, they will have to choose who their #1 guy is. If they feel comfortable making that decision this offseason, it could provide them with some extra cap space to sign a solid RW for Sid. However, although both goalies have shown that they could be solid during stretches, neither has been able to show consistency for a long period. Murray has been up and down and Jarry is in his first real season, where he started strong, but things weren't going as well in the latter part of the season. If the Penguins hold on the both over this summer and allow another full season to go by, they may have a clearer option and really know who their guy is. In this case, you won't have that extra cap space to bring in a RW, and poor play from one of the netminders next season can really hinder their value. What should the Penguins do.. and why do you think that?

Now or else you lose one of them for nothing in the expansion draft

You can make the trade during next season.

Usually you get less value that way