Now
M.Tkachuk - Same player just more skilled IMO
Pettersson - Skill and his confidence is higher rn
Garland - Pretty Even but edged out slightly
Makar(assuming RHD vs RHD) - He's been t5 both years so far
Hughes(^LHD vs LHD) - This was close but hughes had a Calder type rookie year , smith was good but not the best
Campbell - Demko doesn't have a team

5 Years
M.Tkachuk - Slightly
Hughes - NJD Should be good again
If they are both relevant still then Mangiapane
Makar - They will be Close but Makar still
Smith - Pretty Even Offensively but Smith is miles ahead on Defense
Demko - Campbell is probably a backup somewhere

Now
Matthew
Pettersson
Garland
Hughes
Makar
Demko

5 Years
Brady
Pettersson
Garland
Hughes
Makar
Demko

I agree for most but i think Pettersson will always be better than Jack. In 5 years Pettersson wil be like 27 which so the heart of his prime. His best years are in 5 years. Unless Jack can completely ditch us disappointing first two seasons, I don’t think he wil ever be as good as Peter.

Lmao what kind of comparison is Demko and Campbell

Well I look at the teams in 5 years aswell, NJD are trending in a very good way. I won't be surprised if hughes takes a big jump this season

Campbell would be 10x worse then Demko on Vancouver...

It’s true. NJD has a great team in a few years but I also think the Canucks should be also a contending team in 5 years. Most of the core will be in its prime such as Pettersson 27 Hughes 26 Boeser 29. I think Jack Hughes is due for a breakout year by now and I hope he does because it was be very disappointing to the Hughes family.

Well who do you think is better now and in the future?

Not what I meant. The comparison doesn't really make sense. A young up and coming goalie vs a career backup who just turned 30yo and just found his game. Demko vs Hart or Sheskterkin makes more sense.

Campbell won't even be in the league in 5 years....

Hahahah. I made this conpairson because I wasted more than an hour of my life arguing with a Leafs fan who thought that Campbell was better than Demko. Just wanted to see what other people though.

I had a leafs fan ask me to fight today, pretty successful day if you ask me

Jeez where did that happen and why?

In a jack eichel trade thing, I said Eichels value will continue to go down if buffalo doesn't allow him to have his surgery on his neck. He didn't agree and said "he's in my city and I should meet him" or something like that

Lmao I’m gonna have to try to find that. Leafs fans are very good for entertainment

https://www.capfriendly.com/forums/thread/502672/2

IDK if theres a better way to link but thats it, he then thought i used a 2nd account to get him going again

It's true

Well that was quite the thread. Thanks for sharing lol. Imagine actually getting so offended that you ask a person to meet up lmao

I know, as soon as I seen it I knew I won lol

If you’ve ever seen JaredofLondon, that’s the guy who insisted that Campbell was better than Demko while also saying about how “deep the Toronto forward group is” I then later made an ACGM similar to this one asking if people thought Demko or Campbell was better and he reported me and got the Acgm taken down lol

I think I've seen his name before, They all think Brooks, Kampf, Mikheyev, and Engvall are perennial allstars and are worth 2nd Rd picks and higher

Yep.
https://www.capfriendly.com/users/Ed_
Go through this persons ACGMs and look at all the threads and comments. This person enjoys throwing temper tantrums lmao. If you have time to kill and want a good
chuckle, highly recommend looking and their posts.

https://www.capfriendly.com/forums/thread/499080
I recommend this post the most

I found one of his already

Don’t call Ed_ a him or his or they’ll scream at you
According to them, they are a transgender girl, and screamed at me for assuming their gender lol. Needless to say, they are a big fan of all caps