Leafs would decline to take peeke half retained for future considerations delusional, the other trades are fine I guess but I’d hate to see Gregor go maybe swap him with McMann

peeke is another schenn. big, can kind of move the puck, (hes still kind of raw) but he will clear the crease. keep in mind that hes on an awful team, having him or gio as you number 7 id be very happy

Leafs aren’t paying 2.75 for a guy that would head straight down to the minors that’s stupid it’s never gonna happen the guys is the definition of bad he’s gets scored on on will

To borrow from Leafs fans regarding Peeke: "you'd have to pay to dump Timmins, Columbus wouldn't take him half-retained for FC, he's not an NHL D-man".

Now that that's out of the way, we can have an adult conversation. It doesn't make a ton of sense to take a D-man back for CBJ, especially one with term, since it doesn't help the RD logjam. Objectively, yes, Columbus takes that. Realistically, Toronto doesn't offer it; a 1 for 1 swap would be fine if it's a hockey trade/change of scenery thing, hoping that another team's spare parts will fit for both teams.