if im the oilers i do that every day

i feel like we could get more out of them then this, this is just a similar concept to the whole giroux comparable, but everyone has been posting that already

This is probably the likely package idea for Guentzel but imo get either another forward prospect or Beau Akey instead of Broberg. If we get Broberg without having an open spot on the defense then we'll likely have another Ty Smith situation on our hands.

Not even close to getting JG out of Pttsburgh.

Plus his 12 team no trade list probably has Canadian teams on it. Very few Americans want to play in Canada.

fair point, would honestly probably rather Akey. More upside there that we can wait patiently on

It's actually enough or very close considering Dubas is reportedly looking for the "Giroux deal" to move Guentzel

Actually the reported ask is, A Roster player a Blue Chip Prospect and a 1st round pick. Not even close Broberg is on bust level and Holloway has worse numbers then Jonatan Berggren in Detroit and Grand Rapids. Offer is weak.

https://x.com/nhl_watcher/status/1757055179310936413?s=46

Sorry but if Kyle Dubas makes JG available, This would not even be close to the winning bid on him.