Quoting: Warpbox
1 - Very fair. I'm not really sure what the St Louis prospect pool is looking for so I was kinda guessing with my offer.
2 - My reasoning was that generally around this part of the season if players were to get moved, super valuable prospects don't really get included in the deals. Though I could see that being different for Buch as he has those 2 years of team control.
1 - The prospect pool looks like this:
G = great, loaded, including two top 20, if not top 15 G prospects (still counting Hofer in that).
F = great, loaded, two A+ prospects included, as well as another 2-3 A- prospects and a swarm of B-ish prospects on the rise, all on top of young Neighbours now busting out
D = Top 4 LD prospect Lindstein and then a big ol' stack of B/B-/C+ guys, almost all of them LDs, none of them sure bets to be anything more than depth. Maybe I'm underselling Buchinger slightly, but you get the idea.
You see the issue, I'll assume.
2 - Yeah, I hear that a lot. I think some of the Athletic guys and TSN guys love to say it, but it's not as accurate a claim as they portray. It happens.