Quoting: jonh514
First off, I am a little jealous of all the talented players you have on the Sens. That being said, the Sens & Sabres rebuilds are a bit of a cautionary tale. If you look at Detroit for example you might say they did not follow the "rebuild playbook" most teams seem to embrace.
But selling all your veterans and purposefully & perpetually losing for 5+ years to stockpile young talent is a bad strategy. Valuing youth above experience. Valuing talent above grit. It rarely works, but it seems like the league is addicted to this idea. Fans points to Pittsburgh & Chicago and say this is how you build a modern dynasty. But those Pens teams, they didn't only win with Crosby, Malkin & Letang.
Pittsburgh had Guerin (age 38), Gonchar (age 34), Gill (age 33), Boucher (age 35), Cooke (age 30), Dupuis (age 29), Fedetenko (age 30), Eaton (age 31) when they won their first cup of the Crosby dynasty.
Yes Crosby, Malkin, Letang, and Fleury formed the Elite nucleus of the team, but they were surrounded by a veteran core with an average age of 32-33, and since paying the young core priced all the good vets out of the team, the Pens have limped along, never quite good enough to win the last game of the season.
Not even Crosby can do it it alone.
what are you rambling on about they won 2 more cups or did you forget that part. Mainly with a younger team as Rust, Guentzel, Murry, and their 4th line were all part of that next young group coming in.
Furthermore, You are over here comparing a team that in no way would win the todays modern NHL.
The game is faster. You can't just assemble a team of old 32 year old guys now around 3-4 young guys and win. You need to play faster now. It's why the average age of players has decreased since Crosby won that 1st cup.
While I agree it's hard for a team of 22 year olds to win, there is a balance in there where you see teams in the upper 20s really pull it together.
OTT is still a young team. You could say they are underperforming but sometimes that's not just on the players but the coach and office as well.
Remember this was a team that was caught mocking the coach on video not to long ago.
Believe me there are plenty of "old vets" who have bad habits and are guys you really don't want in locker rooms.
You can't look back at OTT and say, oh yeah all those old vets would have been such great influences on these younger players... that's not true. It's better to build with youth than go out and over pay vets to fill roles.