SalarySwishSalarySwish

Erik Karlsson Scouting Reports

Reports: 3
Powered By
The Pro Hockey Group
Note: Reports prior to Sept 2023 were originally graded out of ten, and also included additional categories that have been merged into the current categories.
This likely results in the overall ratings prior to 2023 being decreased in comparison to reports since Sept 2023.

For an `Apples to Apples` comparison between players, we recommend only comparing reports before, or after, Sept 2023.
Results will average out accordingly as more data is accumulated.
Events

Most Recent Report Summary

Talent Type: Professional
Position scouted: Right Defense
Age when scouted: 33
Projection: First Pair
Trending: Under NHL Contract
Birthday: May 31, 1990
Height: 6' 0 | 183 cm
Weight: 190 lbs | 86 kg
Drafted: 15 overall, 2008 round 1 (Logo of the Ottawa Senators OTT)

PROGRESSION

Reports

Report #3

Dec. 13, 2023 (Updated Dec. 15, 2023)
Contract: $92,000,000 over 8 years (Cap hit: $11,500,000)
Position scouted: Right Defense
Age when scouted: 33
82
P1
Projection: First Pair
Trending: Under NHL Contract
Averages over 24:00 TOI
Bulk of his ice time comes at ES and PP#1.
Equal parts distributor / shooter on the PP.
Risk/reward/transitional 'D' who will have lapses in the defensive zone at times ... but his overall commitment from the defensive red line to his net has been better than average overall in Pittsburgh. Not physical. Blocks, on average, at least one shot per game. Area defender.
Criticized for mistakes ... but ... through his first 28GP in a Pens uniform he produced 6G-15A
and was a (+12
Stats Powered by Elite Prospects
SeasonTeamLeagueGPGAP+/-PIM
2023-24Pittsburgh PenguinsNHL82114556444
2022-23San Jose SharksNHL822576101-2636
2021-22San Jose SharksNHL50102535-1414
  • Compete/Consistency: 84
  • Defensive Zone Starts: 75
  • Hockey IQ: 92
  • Offensive Zone Starts: 99
  • Penalty Kill: 0
  • Power Play: 95
  • Physicality: 25
  • Puck Moving/Passing: 95
  • Shot: 86
  • Skating: 86

Report #2

Oct. 10, 2023 (Updated Oct. 11, 2023)
Contract: $92,000,000 over 8 years (Cap hit: $11,500,000)
Position scouted: Right Defense
Age when scouted: 33
82
P1
Projection: First Pair
Trending: Under NHL Contract
Arrives in Pittsburgh fresh off winning the Norris trophy last year in San Jose.
There's no secret about what he brings to the Pens. Pure offense. Transitional 'D'. PP QB
Elite offensively. Thinks the game and executes in the offensive zone at one of the highest rates in the entire NHL.
Averaged 25:36 TOI last season. The majority of his ice time comes at ES and PP#1. He cleaned up at the end of the PK but was not thrust in to a primary role.
Eclipsed 100 points but still finished the season (-26) defensively
Does not engage physically in his zone. An area defender. Was credited with 90 shot blocks.
Risk/reward player. He cuts corners in all three zones to impact the game offensively but his element is exceptionally elite.
Stats Powered by Elite Prospects
SeasonTeamLeagueGPGAP+/-PIM
2023-24Pittsburgh PenguinsNHL82114556444
2022-23San Jose SharksNHL822576101-2636
2021-22San Jose SharksNHL50102535-1414
  • Compete/Consistency: 84
  • Defensive Zone Starts: 75
  • Hockey IQ: 92
  • Offensive Zone Starts: 99
  • Penalty Kill: 0
  • Power Play: 95
  • Physicality: 25
  • Puck Moving/Passing: 95
  • Shot: 86
  • Skating: 86

Report #1

Apr. 4, 2023 (Updated Jun. 22, 2023)
Contract: $92,000,000 over 8 years (Cap hit: $11,500,000)
Position scouted: Right Defense
Age when scouted: 32
67
P1
Projection: First Pair
Trending: Up
Coming off an incredible season offensively. Transitional defenceman. Risk/Reward. Lacks the consistent defensive commitment to be used on the PK or in key defensive zone scenarios
Mid-range battle in the trenches. Limited physical push back.
Elite offensively. Elevated his game offensively in 22/23 and produced the top season of his career. Directed over 200 shots on goal. Sound pace. His legs looked young after enduring some injury setbacks in recent years. Expensive contract and full 'no move clause' gives player complete control of where he goes next.
Stats Powered by Elite Prospects
SeasonTeamLeagueGPGAP+/-PIM
2022-23San Jose SharksNHL822576101-2636
2021-22San Jose SharksNHL50102535-1414
2020-21San Jose SharksNHL5281422-1818
  • Compete/Consistency: 50
  • Defensive Zone Starts: 50
  • Hockey IQ: 73
  • Penalty Kill: 0
  • Power Play: 90
  • Physicality: 13
  • Puck Moving/Passing: 90
  • Shot: 90
  • Skating: 80
Weighting
  • 20%: Compete/Consistency, Hockey IQ, Skating
  • 12%: Puck Moving/Passing
  • 8%: Shot
  • 4%: Defensive Zone Starts, Offensive Zone Starts, Penalty Kill, Power Play, Physicality