SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

goodjobbjs

Member Since
Jul. 24, 2018
Favourite Team
Columbus Blue Jackets
Forum Posts
124
Posts per Day
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GMDec. 2, 2018 at 7:02 p.m.
Thread: Pesce for Shattenkirk
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>goodjobbjs</b></div><div>(b) whether the Rangers would trade Shattenkirk, a first round pick and a prospect for Pesce
I don't think Pesce is worth Shattenkirk a first and prospect in my opinion. The Rangers would avoid giving up such a large amount. Sure I think they would be interested in Pesce but not at that price. A first round pick for the Rangers right now is most likely going to be a lotto pick.

(c) whether Carolina would reject such an offer.

I don't think Carolina could reject that. Depending on the prospect and how the Ranger are doing I think Carolina would happily take that and flip Shattenkirk at the deadline for even more futures. That's a lot of value going to Carolina.</div></div>

Thanks for the input!
Forum: Armchair-GMNov. 16, 2018 at 9:44 p.m.
Thread: Sell High Buy Low All in with Panarin and Bob
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>goodjobbjs</b></div><div>You need to give up pieces if you want a good return. Muzzin has been a fixture on their top pair for years. Toffoli has been scoring 20+ consistantly for a while now. The roster improves significantly. Something like this needs to happen or the jackets will continue to strive for mediocrity. Once Panarin is gone the window closes unless another player of his caliber is brought in.</div></div>

Just for the future, you can hit the quote button to reply to me.


And yes, I know you must give up good stuff to get good stuff. But this trade is just straight horrible for CBJ. right now, Murray is as good, if not better than Muzzin so far this year, he has been GREAT. Plus Robinson and TFW are great prospects who have tons of untapped potential, and our first is likely untouchable unless we get a guy like Stone or Duchene back. Toffoli is not doing good at all, plus we really dont even need him.

I dont mean to be a dick, but this is a bad trade regardless of how you look at it. Muzzin and Toffoli arent worth our current #2 RFA D, a first, TFW, Robinson, plus Milano and Sedsy who imo arent bad trade candidates. Honestly, our D core is probably worse this year if we trade Murray for Muzzin, and Toffoli has been bad even by Kings fans standards.

I agree I undervalued Muzzin, but you're WAY overvaluing him.