sabres1108

Member Since
Jun 20, 2016
Favourite Team
Buffalo Sabres
Birthday
Oct 8, 1992
Forum Posts
1963
Posts per Day
1.65
Forum Threads
459
Forum: Armchair-GMAug 28 at 3:29
Thread: My Custom NHL20 Player Ratings
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Bcarlo25</b></div><div>Or you have a weird bias towards centermen. Understandable. Just think you likely don’t appreciate some of the things d men do</div></div>

not really i mean its pretty simple there is just better forwards than there are dman in the NHL in general

for example

7th best LHD in NHL imo= Torrey Krug who i have at 85

7th best Center in NHL imo= Auston Matthews who i have at 90

its pretty obvious that Krug and matthews should not even be close to having equal ratings

i mean even for depth players-

Ryan Nugent Hopkins former #1 overall pick a very talented, solid two way centerman i have at 85 which ranks him at 33rd best Center in NHL

33rd best LHD on my list? alex edler

should they have the same rating then? absolutely not

RNH&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;Edler

top D men in the NHL are few and far between
Forum: Armchair-GMAug 28 at 3:23
Thread: My Custom NHL20 Player Ratings
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>capfriendlyaccount</b></div><div>I posted this same argument in another one of these threads, but think about it this way:
Top 50 at each position for forwards means 1st/2nd line players, 31 teams x 2 lines per team x = 62 players per position, you are listing 50. You're listing players at as low as 79 overall on these lists. There's a big difference between a second line caliber player and a fourth line caliber player, so if you are listing second liners at &lt;80, what are your fourth liners going to be ranked. Usually the fourth liners aren't any lower than 75. Usually fourth liners are more like 78. The higher end players are usually around 87. Is there really a bigger difference between a borderline all star and a good second liner then there is between that good second liner and a 11th/12th forward?
I don't like the second line players being that low rated.</div></div>


I get what youre saying but its not that simple for a team like ottawa their 2nd line winger could easily be a 4th liner on a team like tampa

but i mean the gaps are pretty fair imo

for example:

Wheeler (1st liner) 88 OVR
Saad (2nd liner) 83 OVR (-5)
Sheary (3rd liner) 78 OVR (-5)
Girgensons (4th liner) 75 OVR (-3)

in general there is a bigger difference between a top 6 fwd than a bottom 6 fwd than there is for a 3rd liner to 4th liner...
Forum: Armchair-GMAug 26 at 2:36
Forum: Armchair-GMAug 21 at 10:34
Forum: Armchair-GMAug 18 at 5:52
Forum: Armchair-GMAug 18 at 4:56