Is this fair and what do you think about 2nd line

Beside the fact that it’s very hard to see these two teams making a trade. I find it hard to believe when they said top 6 player Rust would qualify. He bounces back and forth from 40-50 point seasons which is fine, but can’t really be all that appealing when you’re talking about a contract that has 5+ years on it at 5m+. Capitals certainly can’t ask for much here, but they’d probably be better off just waiting for a different offer given their future uncertainty

No he wouldn't. He's made it clear on multiple occasions he's retiring a Penguin.

I can see Jeff might not wave but for a 4 hr drive it is close enough between ridding the bench with pens or playing he might do it. Also for rust not being a top 6 yes I know 2 different styles of playing but he scores more than Tom Wilson. Wilson just inked for more money.

Not taking on that Rust contract

Without even getting into the trade - both Rust and Carter have NMCs. Having them both waive for a team that most likely finishes lower in the standings is probably like lottery odds.

As for the fairness of the actual trade - I'd say it's light. I don't think Carter or Rust carry much value to the Caps right now - would need to add picks/prospects