Quoting: netminder71
So BMac / Krak / Eli -- all you Caps fans out there (like me)....what do we REALLY expect this deadline?? We all know they are looking for D because Trotz does not trust Bowey in post season and the mistakes are piling up for Orpik (an even Djoos last night looked off).
So what is the reality?
First of all, thanks for the shoutout, Netminder71!
MacLellan seems like a straight shooter. He says he's getting defense, so he's getting defense.
I think he or Trotz said something a couple years ago about liking to have three right handed guys and three left handed guys, so if they trade Bowey(right handed) for Leddy (left handed) they're going to be adding defense.
There was something about MacLellan's tone when he rejected the idea of trading Orpik instead of Johansson last summer to make cap space that says to me he still isn't going to dump Orpik,because he believes Orpik is elite within his own zone. So I don't expect that move, let alone an overpayment to make it happen.
I'd be surprised if they paid much to rent Green, given Green's past failings in a shutdown role, but I wouldn't be too surprised or bothered to see Green on a cheap long term deal this coming summer instead of Carlson. It's been a while, but Green certainly has the knowledge and skills to score goals on power plays and in overtime.
I think last deadline they overspent to rent Shattenkirk and didn't get any further than the year before, not renting anyone, so more likely they rent a right handed Chorney and an old forward for next to nothing.
In my head they're likely to try to sell high on Djoos to bring in a top defenseman on either side, and bring in a cheap plug for the other side, and rent a meh center.
The idea that Orpik is a bad player comes down to whether you value speed over checking and crease clearing. Plenty of good teams are built each way. There's still no one answer. For each parade of penalties in the early season, there's a playoff series with, like, ten minors called, total.