Edited Mar. 20, 2020 at 9:34 p.m.
Schenn and Reimer in their Leafs career were both good, admittedly they both suck now, same as Gunnar and Stralman both were meh Leaf players but became good afterwards. Robertson and Woll have proven nothing and shouldn't be here, where's Drake Berehowski ?
G. McKegg
K. Holzer
J. Leivo
D. Timashov
A. Brooks
A. Bibeau
And as the other comment said, Mikheyev doesn't count, but the other big Russian kid does, Korshkov.
Holy crap, looking at hockeydb, the worst draft in history must belong to the Leafs 1999 year, 9 players picks, only 3 NHL games totaled played.
1996 draft was saved by the luck of getting Kaberle in the 8th Rd. 12 players drafted by the Leafs before him, total = 21 NHL games. Kaberle = 900+ games.