Yeah, no thanks. You guys get the best player and a first? Not happening.

no

Leafs decline

i definitely agree with with you all, but i’m curious.
i like the return and i’m interested what you would add or subtract to make this a fair deal.
I think Manson could fit well along side Rielly, and others do have different opinions but that is mine. I also think Rakell could soften the blow to the top 6 without Nylander there, assuming he is going the other way. and Heinen, i’ve just always kinda liked him.

To start drop all the picks and it's a decent base I would say all the retention is worth a 2nd and a 4th or 5th not sure about the lengths of all the incoming contracts.

I agree. I’ve heard from a lot of Ducks fans that they’d take Nylander alone for Manson and Rakell. Johnsson is better than Heinen, however i would like to keep Johnsson, whether that is Dubas’ plan or not, I would like to see him stay. So maybe Holl and two seconds get Heinen and retention. maybe not all that retention but at least a bit. Something like Nylander, Holl, 2021 2nd, 2022 2nd for Rakell, Manson, Heinen. with retention being whatever is needed?

I would say no if the Leafs would only trade away Nylander and nothing else

It's a lot to take in but take out the first round pick and I think I'd probably make the trade