Quoting: JuniorGM
Quoting: F50marco
I just feel Winnipeg is winning this deal. Edmonton is coming out good and Nashville is getting gypped.
Please explain how nashville is losing... Little (so underrated 2 way top 6 center), Davidson cheap can play in your top 4 and a 1-2 round pick? For a good top 4 dman and a good bottom 6 forward. Thats good value. All teams improve their weaknesses. Its a cool idea.
First off, the trade was modified after i posted my comment. It was only Little and Davidson at first.
So just going off of what was first mentioned.
Winnipeg receives arguably the best dman or at least a very close second best. The best center or at the very least very close second best.
Edmonton gets arguably the best dman or at least a very close second best. Also a decent top 6-9 player.
Nashville gets best center or at the very least very close second best. Also a decent barely top 4 dman.
Hmmmmmm if I'm choosing here I think Winnipeg is running away with this deal like effing hyenas. Little is a smallish second line center whose 28 with only 2 years left on his contract and also has been injured a lot lately. Davidson is a decent player but he's barely a top 4 dman IN EDMONTON.
Now if we change the deal as Ultraman has done here, its starting to make more sense now. Nashville receiving a 1st rounder makes this deal more palatable. The thing is something still feels wrong in all this, so lets break it down.
Trouba , RNH and Ekholm are essentially even at this point. Give or take a little bit either way to make it work.
But the rest is where it feels off
Little and a conditional 1st rounder, Davidson and Wilson/Jarnkrok. Who out of this group seems out of place? In my opinion its Davidson, Jarnkrok and the 1st rounder. Little is the best piece in the rest of this deal. Then its Wilson/ 1st rounder, then its Davidson and Jarnkrok. WPG is giving to much while EDM not enough.
So lets do exactly what is trying to be done here without all the other added filler:
Winnipeg gives: Trouba
Edmonton gives: RNH
Nashville gives: Ekholm
Edmonton receives: Trouba
Winnipeg receives: Ekholm
Nashville receives: RNH
Boom. Everyone gets what they want while giving up something they already have a lot of.