Speed- Mcdavid (with puck). Straight line skating, didn't barzal beat Mcdavids record at the all-star game? Or Larkin? I thought someone did. With puck tho easily Mcdavid.
Age- Mcdavid
Skill- Could argue either way. Slightly different skill sets. Offense Mcdavid, 200 foot game Mackinnon.
Points- Again tough to compare based on strength of team. if you put Mcdavid on Colorado and Mackinnon on EDM I would think Mcdavid gets more points easily every year, although draisatl, idk.
Defense- Mackinnon
Contract value- Easily Mackinnon by far. BY FAR.
Leadership- Tough to argue this one either way. I'll say Mcdavid for putting up with what he does in EDM and never complaining.