Quoting: DirtyDangles
You think W is your strongest position? Having a logjam of meh doesn’t make you strong. As for your Flyers comparison, it’s a false equivalency. Where is the $6 mil cap dump?
We certainly don't have a logjam of meh wingers. Here's our depth chart.
Kuzmenko: 39 G - 35 A - 74 PTS in 81 GP (0.91 PPG)
Boeser: 18 G - 37 A - 55 PTS in 74 GP (0.74 PPG) Note that these numbers were put up in what every is calling a major down year
Mikheyev: 13 G - 15 A - 28 PTS in 46 GP (0.61 PPG) Mikheyev put up those numbers while playing with a partially torn ACL before finally deciding to undergo surgery
Beauvillier: 9 G - 11 A - 20 PTS in 33 GP (0.61 PPG)
Garland: 17 G - 29 A - 46 PTS in 81 GP (0.57 PPG)
Beyond those 5 we still have our young prospects in Hoglander and Podkolzin who are both looking at NHL time as well as Joshua and Studnicka who will get NHL playing time. If that's not our strongest position I don't know what is.
Pettersson - Miller is a good 1-2 punch at C, but we don't have any depth beyond that. Dries and Aman slot in as the next guys in the depth chart, but neither are more than a depth forward on most other teams.
Hughes is a great #1 d-man. Hronek can slot in nicely as a #3 on the 2nd pair, but the rest of our defence is pretty much 3rd pair/depth guys.
Demko is a great goalie, but is coming off a down year and an injury. Delia and Martin were our backups last year, posting an .882 and .871 SV% each.
None of those 3 positions are close to our strongest. Winger is by far our best position.
This deal just makes no sense for the Canucks. We need defence, centre depth, and prospects. Winger is the last thing we need. This deal would leave us with the following roster:
Kuzmenko - Pettersson - Konecny
Mikheyev - Miller - Boeser
Beauvillier - Dries - Garland
Joshua - Aman - Studnicka
Hughes - Hronek
OEL
Bear
Demko - Martin
Di Giuseppe - Brisebois
That leaves us with $3 mil to sign a 2nd pair RHD and a 3rd pair LHD, assuming Bear takes $2.5 mil. We can trade Garland to give us $8 mil to sign those 2 defenceman. However, this team is not a contender at all. The defence is weak and there is no depth down the middle. The team is objectively worse than what we could put together otherwise. Not only is the team worse, but we also lose pick 11 in a stacked draft and weaken on of the weakest prospect pools in the league even further.