I'd take Risto if he were 50% retained, otherwise, I hope the Leafs don't trade for him. I doubt Philly retains for 4 years though.

No to the 1st in this deal for Risto.

that is a super generous deal for Edmonton

Edmonton says yes

Leafs won’t be using that first on anyone except tanev Hanifin or larsson

Leafs decline, Ristolainen is absolutely horrible

Not really. Atkinson is overpaid too and have you seen his age. He could crater next year. There’s risks you haven’t considered.

Also Holloway is a guaranteed NHLer, If you actually know the player. He was finally looking great right before injury, it was very unfortunate timing, feel sorry for the kid. But when he’s back he’s going to be good for the Oilers.

Walker is only a rental too. And he’s walking to UFA to seek maximum pay day after his couple months here. So we’d have to get rid of Ceci to even to fit him in, and he doesn’t know the group, comes in and does who knows what, cause this is the first time in his whole career he’s done anything.

The money doesn’t even work.

The money has to work for edmonton to consider, after we’re done trading you Campbell we will have nothing.

I would counter:

1st 2024
Broberg
Campbell
Bourgault
Ceci
Ryan

If Laughton is coming in to be 4C, Ryan has to go.
Same with Ceci. Both are decent players and can be flipped by the flyers anyways for more futures.

Atkinson at his worst is still better than Campbell and it's only one year after this one
Walker at half price as a rental is more than fair for Broberg, proven NHLer who can play top4 for an unproven 7th D\prospect is fairly standard trade.
Laughton is worth more than Holloway, not really close
I could go on