Bad trade for the Islanders Nelson himself could get a better package Minten just isn’t that great of a prospect. With retainment he should fetch more not to mention adding Dufour and Bolduc doesn’t make sense at all

Minten is easily the best prospect in the Islanders system after this trade.

He was team Canada's captain at the world juniors. Before him in that role in order: Wright, McTavish, Byram, Cozens, Dach.

If he's 80% as good as any of those guys he is better than any prospects anyone would offer for Nelson 1 for 1.

Minten was also one of if not the worst team Canada captain. You’re absolutely insane if you think he is even close to Nelson’s value. An elite 2nd line center 75 point 30 goal player fetches a way higher price than a point per game WHL player and a 1st.

I see where you are coming from but Nelson is 32. Nobody is paying that price. Not a knock on him but he's only passed 50 5v5 points once in his career so unless a team needs a PP1 guy (which no current contenders do) then he's a 40-45 point player for whoever is acquiring him. He's 47% on the draws so he's not going to be valued highly as a C.

For reference Max Domi has 3 5v5 points less than Nelson, 2% better on the draws and has played more than 240 minutes less than Nelson.

He crushes Nelson in every /60 5v5 offensive and defensive stat.

Would you pay a 1st and top prospect for Domi? Cause analytically he's a significantly better player.

Have you seen the Isles' system? "Best prospect in the system" is a very low bar to clear.

He’s just not even close analytically to Nelson xGF, FF%, GF%, CF% this season. In the past 3 seasons Domi has a combined 6.5 xOFF while Nelson has 47.8 xOFF. OFF Domi has 24.5 in the last 3 seasons while Nelson has 35.8 never mention Domi as a comparison again they are not even close. Not to mention Nelson is better defensively in the past 3 seasons as well, better shooter, better play driver and better on the pp your argument is a fallacy. Nelson has been on pace for 50 even strength points 3 times in the past 5 seasons and Domi has only been on a 50 point even pace ONCE in his CAREER. Pasternak also finished higher in EV points than Mcdavid last year does that mean Pasta> Mcdavid absolutely not it means that powerplay is also valuable WOW.