SalarySwishSalarySwish
Forums/Mock-Draft

Will Scouch List

Will Scouch List

Draft Class: 2024
Created By: NHLfan10506
Published: Apr. 22 at 7:37 a.m.
Description
The draft list of Will Scouch (who runs scouching.ca website and is @Scouching on X). He uses analytics and his lists often differ from others.

Here is the link: https://www.scouching.ca/the-blog/scouchings-penultimate-2024-nhl-draft-ranking

I have listed the consensus rank along with each to show the deviation from the norm. The consensus rank is derived from averaging the ranking of about 20 well-known scouts, scouting services and draft observers.

He has 105 players on his list

His tiers...

-- Tier I: #1 though #4
-- Tier II: #5 through #18
-- Tier III: #19 through #32
-- Tier IV: #33 through #66
-- Tier V: # 67 though #80
-- Tier VI: #81 through #105

The top ranked players (according to consensus ranking) that are not in his top-105
-- #28 Terik Parascak
-- #31 EJ Emery
-- #32 Maxim Masse
-- #33 Henry Mews
-- #38 Leo Sahlin Wallenius

-- #61 Christian Humphreys
-- #65 Niilopekka Muhonen
-- #66 Simon Zether
-- #70 Arvid Westlin
-- #71 Eric Burger

-- #72 Tuomas Suoniemi
-- #77 Max Plante
-- #78 Justin Poirier
-- #79 Spencer Gill
-- #80 Ryerson Leenders

-- #81 Austin Baker
-- #82 Jack Berglund
-- #84 Carter George
-- #86 Melvin Fernstrom
-- #88 Lukas Fischer

-- #92 Tarin Smith
-- #94 Anthony Cristoforo
-- #96 Luca Marrelli
-- #97 Riley Patterson
-- #98 Colin Ralph

-- #99 Colton Roberts
-- #102 Lucas Van Vliet
-- #103 Thomas Desruisseaux
-- #105 Sam O'Reilly
-- #106 Will Zellers
Lottery Winners:
  1. Logo of the Calgary FlamesCalgary Flames (9→1)
  2. Logo of the Montreal CanadiensMontreal Canadiens (5→2)
ROUND 1TEAMORIGINALPLAYERDETAILS
1Logo of the Calgary Flames-Expert Consensus Rank: #1 (start of Tier I)
2Logo of the Montreal Canadiens-Expert Consensus Rank: #2
3Logo of the San Jose Sharks-Expert Consensus Rank: #4
4Logo of the Chicago Blackhawks-Expert Consensus Rank: #6
5Logo of the Anaheim Ducks-Expert Consensus Rank: #34 (start of Tier II)
6Logo of the Columbus Blue Jackets-Expert Consensus Rank: #18
7Logo of the Arizona Coyotes-Expert Consensus Rank: #8
8Logo of the Ottawa Senators-Expert Consensus Rank: #3
9Logo of the Seattle Kraken-Expert Consensus Rank: #16
10Logo of the New Jersey Devils-Expert Consensus Rank: #12
11Logo of the Buffalo Sabres-Expert Consensus Rank: #15
12Logo of the Philadelphia Flyers-Expert Consensus Rank: #13
13Logo of the Minnesota Wild-Expert Consensus Rank: #27
14Logo of the San Jose SharksLogo of the Pittsburgh PenguinsExpert Consensus Rank: #5
15Logo of the Detroit Red Wings-Expert Consensus Rank: #10
16Logo of the Washington Capitals-Expert Consensus Rank: #17
17Logo of the St. Louis Blues-Expert Consensus Rank: #35
18Logo of the New York Islanders-Expert Consensus Rank: #9
19Logo of the Vegas Golden Knights-Expert Consensus Rank: #22 (start of Tier III)
20Logo of the Chicago BlackhawksLogo of the Tampa Bay LightningExpert Consensus Rank: #7
21Logo of the Los Angeles Kings-Expert Consensus Rank: #29
22Logo of the Nashville Predators-Expert Consensus Rank: #54
23Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs-Expert Consensus Rank: #24
24Logo of the Anaheim DucksLogo of the Edmonton OilersExpert Consensus Rank: #11
25Logo of the Colorado Avalanche-Expert Consensus Rank: #20
26Logo of the Ottawa SenatorsLogo of the Boston BruinsExpert Consensus Rank: #62
27Logo of the Calgary FlamesLogo of the Vancouver CanucksExpert Consensus Rank: #40
28Logo of the Philadelphia FlyersLogo of the Florida PanthersExpert Consensus Rank: #58
29Logo of the Montreal CanadiensLogo of the Winnipeg JetsExpert Consensus Rank: #30
30Logo of the Carolina Hurricanes-Expert Consensus Rank: #52
31Logo of the Dallas Stars-Expert Consensus Rank: #23
32Logo of the New York Rangers-Expert Consensus Rank: #59
ROUND 2TEAMORIGINALPLAYERDETAILS
33Logo of the San Jose Sharks-
Noel Fransen
Expert Consensus Rank: #63 (start of Tier IV)
34Logo of the Chicago Blackhawks-Expert Consensus Rank: #37
35Logo of the Anaheim Ducks-Expert Consensus Rank: #39
36Logo of the Philadelphia FlyersLogo of the Columbus Blue JacketsExpert Consensus Rank: #69
37Logo of the Winnipeg JetsLogo of the Montreal CanadiensExpert Consensus Rank: #21
38Logo of the Arizona Coyotes-Expert Consensus Rank: #85
39Logo of the Ottawa Senators-Expert Consensus Rank: #14
40Logo of the Seattle Kraken-Expert Consensus Rank: #19
41Logo of the Calgary Flames-Expert Consensus Rank: #41
42Logo of the San Jose SharksLogo of the New Jersey DevilsExpert Consensus Rank: #44
43Logo of the Buffalo Sabres-Expert Consensus Rank: #94
44Logo of the Pittsburgh PenguinsLogo of the Philadelphia FlyersExpert Consensus Rank: #136
45Logo of the Minnesota Wild-
Yegor Graf
Expert Consensus Rank: #50
46Logo of the Pittsburgh Penguins-Expert Consensus Rank: #87
47Logo of the Detroit Red Wings-
Jiri Tichacek
Expert Consensus Rank: #139
48Logo of the Arizona CoyotesLogo of the Washington CapitalsExpert Consensus Rank: #25
49Logo of the St. Louis Blues-Expert Consensus Rank: #124
50Logo of the New York Islanders-Expert Consensus Rank: #72
51Logo of the Philadelphia Flyers-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
52Logo of the Washington CapitalsLogo of the Vegas Golden KnightsExpert Consensus Rank: #47
53Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Tampa Bay LightningExpert Consensus Rank: #60
54Logo of the Chicago BlackhawksLogo of the Los Angeles Kings
Mitch Young
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
55Logo of the Nashville Predators-Expert Consensus Rank: #52
56Logo of the St. Louis BluesLogo of the Toronto Maple LeafsExpert Consensus Rank: #26
57Logo of the Edmonton Oilers-Expert Consensus Rank: #64
58Logo of the Montreal CanadiensLogo of the Colorado AvalancheExpert Consensus Rank: #76
59Logo of the Anaheim DucksLogo of the Boston BruinsExpert Consensus Rank: #97
60Logo of the Chicago BlackhawksLogo of the Vancouver CanucksExpert Consensus Rank: #42
61Logo of the Arizona CoyotesLogo of the Florida PanthersExpert Consensus Rank: #68
62Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Winnipeg JetsExpert Consensus Rank: #36
63Logo of the Carolina Hurricanes-Expert Consensus Rank: #45
64Logo of the Calgary FlamesLogo of the Dallas StarsExpert Consensus Rank: #67
65Logo of the Seattle KrakenLogo of the New York RangersExpert Consensus Rank: #110
ROUND 3TEAMORIGINALPLAYERDETAILS
66Logo of the Anaheim DucksLogo of the San Jose SharksExpert Consensus Rank: #48
67Logo of the Chicago Blackhawks-
Ilya Protas
Expert Consensus Rank: #159 (start of Tier V)
68Logo of the Anaheim Ducks-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
69Logo of the Columbus Blue Jackets-Expert Consensus Rank: #43
70Logo of the Montreal Canadiens-Expert Consensus Rank: #56
71Logo of the Arizona Coyotes-Expert Consensus Rank: #51
72Logo of the Chicago BlackhawksLogo of the Ottawa SenatorsExpert Consensus Rank: #55
73Logo of the Seattle Kraken-Expert Consensus Rank: #106
74Logo of the Calgary Flames-Expert Consensus Rank: #57
75Logo of the New Jersey Devils-Expert Consensus Rank: #83
76Logo of the Buffalo Sabres-Expert Consensus Rank: #49
77Logo of the Philadelphia Flyers-Expert Consensus Rank: #91
78Logo of the Montreal CanadiensLogo of the Minnesota Wild
Ludvig Johnson
Expert Consensus Rank: #88
79Logo of the Anaheim DucksLogo of the Pittsburgh PenguinsExpert Consensus Rank: #93
80Logo of the Detroit Red Wings-Expert Consensus Rank: #134
81Logo of the Washington Capitals-Expert Consensus Rank: #46 (start of Tier I)
82Logo of the St. Louis Blues-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
83Logo of the Washington CapitalsLogo of the New York Islanders
Jacob Therrien
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
84Logo of the Calgary FlamesLogo of the Vegas Golden KnightsExpert Consensus Rank: #103
85Logo of the San Jose SharksLogo of the Tampa Bay LightningExpert Consensus Rank: n/a
86Logo of the Columbus Blue JacketsLogo of the Los Angeles KingsExpert Consensus Rank: #112
87Logo of the Nashville Predators-Expert Consensus Rank: #130
88Logo of the Seattle KrakenLogo of the Toronto Maple LeafsExpert Consensus Rank: #99
89Logo of the Arizona CoyotesLogo of the Edmonton OilersExpert Consensus Rank: #72
90Logo of the Arizona CoyotesLogo of the Colorado AvalancheExpert Consensus Rank: n/a
91Logo of the Washington CapitalsLogo of the Boston Bruins
Eemil Laurell
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
92Logo of the Vancouver Canucks-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
93Logo of the Florida Panthers-
Kenta Isogai
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
94Logo of the New Jersey DevilsLogo of the Winnipeg JetsExpert Consensus Rank: n/a
95Logo of the Carolina Hurricanes-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
96Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Dallas StarsExpert Consensus Rank: #124
97Logo of the St. Louis BluesLogo of the New York RangersExpert Consensus Rank: n/a
ROUND 4TEAMORIGINALPLAYERDETAILS
98Logo of the Arizona CoyotesLogo of the San Jose Sharks
William Nicholl
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
99Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Chicago Blackhawks
Joel Abrahamsson
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
100Logo of the Anaheim Ducks-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
101Logo of the Columbus Blue Jackets-Expert Consensus Rank: #128
102Logo of the Montreal Canadiens-
Gavin Uhlenkamp
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
103Logo of the Arizona Coyotes-
Anton Bitev
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
104Logo of the Ottawa Senators-Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
105Logo of the Seattle Kraken-
Cedrick Johansson
Expert Consensus Rank: n/a
106Logo of the Calgary Flames-
107Logo of the Calgary FlamesLogo of the New Jersey Devils
108Logo of the Buffalo Sabres-
109Logo of the Buffalo SabresLogo of the Philadelphia Flyers
110Logo of the Minnesota Wild-
111Logo of the Pittsburgh Penguins-
112Logo of the Ottawa SenatorsLogo of the Detroit Red Wings
113Logo of the Washington Capitals-
114Logo of the St. Louis Blues-
115Logo of the New York Islanders-
116Logo of the San Jose SharksLogo of the Vegas Golden Knights
117Logo of the Ottawa SenatorsLogo of the Tampa Bay Lightning
118Logo of the Los Angeles Kings-
119Logo of the Nashville Predators-
120Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs-
121Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Edmonton Oilers
122Logo of the Colorado Avalanche-
123Logo of the Boston Bruins-
124Logo of the Vancouver Canucks-
125Logo of the Ottawa SenatorsLogo of the Florida Panthers
126Logo of the Winnipeg Jets-
127Logo of the Carolina Hurricanes-
128Logo of the Detroit Red WingsLogo of the Dallas Stars
129Logo of the New York Rangers-
Apr. 22 at 10:54 a.m.
#1
BDHockey
Avatar of the user
Joined: Nov. 2023
Posts: 1,004
Likes: 421
His lists are always interesting if nothing else. Relying too heavily on analytics will cause weird things to happen. I wonder how accurate his previous rankings have been.
Apr. 22 at 10:57 a.m.
#2
Lancebmx
Avatar of the user
Joined: Oct. 2020
Posts: 10,602
Likes: 8,217
Quoting: BDHockey
His lists are always interesting if nothing else. Relying too heavily on analytics will cause weird things to happen. I wonder how accurate his previous rankings have been.


I was about to say the same thing about his previous listings. Would be interesting to see how well he projects.
NHLfan10506 liked this.
Apr. 22 at 2:36 p.m.
#3
NHLfan10506
Thread Starter
Avatar of the user
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 40,433
Likes: 18,435
Quoting: BDHockey
His lists are always interesting if nothing else. Relying too heavily on analytics will cause weird things to happen. I wonder how accurate his previous rankings have been.


2020 (actual)
1. Alexis Lafreniere (1)
2. Quinton Byfield (2)
3. Marco Rossi (9)
4. Lucas Raymond (4)
5. Tim Stutzle (3)

6. Cole Perfetti (10)
7. Jamie Drysdale (6)
8. Alexander Holtz (7)
9. Yaroslav Askarov (11)
10. Anton Lundell (12)

11. Rodion Amirov (15)
12. Marat Khusnutdinov (37)
13. Seth Jarvis (13)
14. Jake Sanderson (5)
15. Mavrik Bourque (30)

16. Dawson Mercer (18)
17. Dylan Holloway (14)
18. Noel Gunler (41)
19. Lukas Reichel (17)
20. William Wallinder (32)

21. Jacob Perreault (27)
22. Jack Quinn (8)
23. John-Jason Peterka (34)
24. Daniil Gushchin (76)
25. Ozzy Wiesblatt (31)

26. Connor Zary (24)
27. Jan Mysak (48)
28. Hendrix Lapierre (22)
29. Helge Grans (35)
30. Roni Hirvonen (59)


2021 (actual)
1. Matthew Beniers (2)
2. William Eklund (7)
3. Jesper Wallstedt (20)
4. Fabian Lysell (21)
5. Luke Hughes (4)

6. Kent Johnson (5)
7. Owen Power (1)
8. Simon Edvinsson (6)
9. Brandt Clarke (8)
10. Dylan Guenther (9)

11. Mason McTavish (3)
12. Aatu Raty (52)
13. Fyodor Svechkov (19)
14. Logan Stankoven (47)
15. Cole Sillinger (12)

16. Simon Robertsson (71)
17. Isak Rosen (14)
18. Matthew Coronato (13)
19. Carson Lambos (26)
20. Chaz Lucius (18)

21. Scott Morrow (40)
22. Nikita Chibrikov (50)
23. Stanislav Svozil (69)
24. Sebastian Cossa (15)
25. Ville Koivunen (51)

26. Oskar Olausson (28)
27. Matthew Samoskevich (24)
28. Ayrton Martino (73)
29. William Stromgren (45)
30. Xavier Bourgault (22)


2022 (actual)
1. Shane Wright (4)
2. Brad Lambert (30)
3. Logan Cooley (3)
4. David Jiricek (6)
5. Juraj Slafkovsky (1)

6. Cutter Gauthier (5)
7. Matthew Savoie (9)
8. Gleb Trikozov (60)
9. Seamus Casey (46)
10. Joakim Kemell (17)

11. Filip Mesar (26)
12. Simon Nemec (2)
13. Isaac Howard (31)
14. Liam Ohgren (19)
15. Frank Nazar (13)

16. Kevin Korchinski (7)
17. Vladimir Grudinin (156)
18. Pavel Mintyukov (10)
19. Danila Yurov (24)
20. Noah Ostlund (16)

21. Jonathan Lekkerimaki (15)
22. Owen Pickering (21)
23. Calle Odelius (65)
24. Jiri Kulich (28)
25. Conor Geekie (11)

26. Sam Rinzel (25)
27. Denton Mateychuk (12)
28. Jagger Firkus (35)
29. Paul Ludwinski (39)
30. Marco Kasper (8)
Apr. 22 at 2:37 p.m.
#4
NHLfan10506
Thread Starter
Avatar of the user
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 40,433
Likes: 18,435
Quoting: Lancebmx
I was about to say the same thing about his previous listings. Would be interesting to see how well he projects.


see above
Apr. 22 at 2:41 p.m.
#5
BDHockey
Avatar of the user
Joined: Nov. 2023
Posts: 1,004
Likes: 421
Quoting: NHLfan10506
2020 (actual)
1. Alexis Lafreniere (1)
2. Quinton Byfield (2)
3. Marco Rossi (9)
4. Lucas Raymond (4)
5. Tim Stutzle (3)

6. Cole Perfetti (10)
7. Jamie Drysdale (6)
8. Alexander Holtz (7)
9. Yaroslav Askarov (11)
10. Anton Lundell (12)

11. Rodion Amirov (15)
12. Marat Khusnutdinov (37)
13. Seth Jarvis (13)
14. Jake Sanderson (5)
15. Mavrik Bourque (30)

16. Dawson Mercer (18)
17. Dylan Holloway (14)
18. Noel Gunler (41)
19. Lukas Reichel (17)
20. William Wallinder (32)

21. Jacob Perreault (27)
22. Jack Quinn (8)
23. John-Jason Peterka (34)
24. Daniil Gushchin (76)
25. Ozzy Wiesblatt (31)

26. Connor Zary (24)
27. Jan Mysak (48)
28. Hendrix Lapierre (22)
29. Helge Grans (35)
30. Roni Hirvonen (59)


2021 (actual)
1. Matthew Beniers (2)
2. William Eklund (7)
3. Jesper Wallstedt (20)
4. Fabian Lysell (21)
5. Luke Hughes (4)

6. Kent Johnson (5)
7. Owen Power (1)
8. Simon Edvinsson (6)
9. Brandt Clarke (8)
10. Dylan Guenther (9)

11. Mason McTavish (3)
12. Aatu Raty (52)
13. Fyodor Svechkov (19)
14. Logan Stankoven (47)
15. Cole Sillinger (12)

16. Simon Robertsson (71)
17. Isak Rosen (14)
18. Matthew Coronato (13)
19. Carson Lambos (26)
20. Chaz Lucius (18)

21. Scott Morrow (40)
22. Nikita Chibrikov (50)
23. Stanislav Svozil (69)
24. Sebastian Cossa (15)
25. Ville Koivunen (51)

26. Oskar Olausson (28)
27. Matthew Samoskevich (24)
28. Ayrton Martino (73)
29. William Stromgren (45)
30. Xavier Bourgault (22)


2022 (actual)
1. Shane Wright (4)
2. Brad Lambert (30)
3. Logan Cooley (3)
4. David Jiricek (6)
5. Juraj Slafkovsky (1)

6. Cutter Gauthier (5)
7. Matthew Savoie (9)
8. Gleb Trikozov (60)
9. Seamus Casey (46)
10. Joakim Kemell (17)

11. Filip Mesar (26)
12. Simon Nemec (2)
13. Isaac Howard (31)
14. Liam Ohgren (19)
15. Frank Nazar (13)

16. Kevin Korchinski (7)
17. Vladimir Grudinin (156)
18. Pavel Mintyukov (10)
19. Danila Yurov (24)
20. Noah Ostlund (16)

21. Jonathan Lekkerimaki (15)
22. Owen Pickering (21)
23. Calle Odelius (65)
24. Jiri Kulich (28)
25. Conor Geekie (11)

26. Sam Rinzel (25)
27. Denton Mateychuk (12)
28. Jagger Firkus (35)
29. Paul Ludwinski (39)
30. Marco Kasper (8)


Yeah these are kind of wacky.
Playersoverpayed liked this.
Apr. 23 at 7:18 p.m.
#6
TyeZerker
Avatar of the user
Joined: Jul. 2023
Posts: 1,122
Likes: 164
Connelly and Nygrad are way too high. both arent even top 12 picks.
 
Reply
To create a post please Login or Register
Question:
Options:
Add Option
Submit Poll