SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

PenGoater99

Analytics are good
Member Since
Jan. 21, 2018
Favourite Team
Pittsburgh Penguins
Forum Posts
3604
Posts per Day
1.6
Forum: Armchair-GMFeb. 9, 2018 at 4:05 p.m.
Thread: What we could get for every player
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>hockeysmartman</b></div><div>How</div></div>

If you like, I can go through every of these trades and what's wrong with them.

Ahem

CGY trade = Shinkaruk has pretty much lost his value, he is currently an 23-year-old AHL player who's future in NHL was pretty much sealed when he was traded from VAN to CGY. It's likely he'll be never making a big difference in the big leagues.

ARI trade = That's actually stupid for both teams. Arizona could very well do that trade, because Arizona can actually afford to bring pretty much any deal that Karlsson wants. Both of these d-men are going to be UFAs after next season. But I doubt that neither of those players will be staying in their former teams because their former teams are quite weak. If you want to trade Karlsson, please trade it for future assets, not for another UFA who would be pretty much as hard to keep as the former one.

NYI (smith) trade = C'mon, Smith is not that good, and NYI isn't in such a need for that kind of center. They're looking for a D, if I'm correct.

CHI trade = Ottawa would lose in that trade. They wasted a great amount of good assets for Duchene, so it's pretty much pointless just trade him for a less skillful version of himself.

ANA trade = Because of Anderson's new contract, ANA cannot take his contract. They need to save money for Gibson's new contract.

MTL trade = Ok that's decent for Habs. They need a C. But considering that Byron has been pretty decent this season, they'd probably skip. I'd offer Pageau to a contending team such as PIT. Would likely get a better return.

FLA trade = Säteri has been a savior for Panthers, he has been very good. If they decide to trade him, I bet they wouldn't trade him for a goalie. They already have Luongo and Reimer.

DET trade = Do you even watch hockey? Franzen will never play again due to concussion. His trade value is nothing. That is a definition pointless trade.

NYI (pääjärvi) trade = He was just claimed from waivers. Nobody will spend a pick on him, unless they really need a winger. NYI does not.

LA (macarthur) trade = MacArthur won't be playing this season either. Nobody will pay anything for him because of the risk that he cannot play ever again.

NSH trade = Center depth is basically the thing Preds don't need, they already have 6-7 of them. Besides, both of those C's were taken from waivers, so that pretty much tells how "valuable they are"

CBJ = Yeah, who trades a potential TOP-6 forward and a second round pick for two fourth-liners? Probably you would, but any sane manager wouldn't.

LA (white) trade = White has potential to be a TOP6 forward, and you'd like to trade him to a forward that is declining badly and has a horrendous contract.

You know what? The more I'm going through this, the more I think this is just a joke. There's bunch of trades more, but I'm already done. Point has been made pretty much clear.
Forum: Armchair-GMFeb. 5, 2018 at 12:08 p.m.
Thread: Most likely
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>PenGoater99</b></div><div>Dallas: Fair enough
Toronto: They don't need another 6/7 d-man
NYI: Not enough for Nelson
Nashville: Way too much for a 3rd liner
Winnipeg: I doubt they give up Dano for a 6/7 d-man
Pittsburgh: Retain half of the 6 mil to make it go through or take out the 5th</div></div>

I agree on Dallas, Toronto, NYI, Pitts... but not the others;

Dallas: Fair enough= I agree OK
Toronto: They don't need another 6/7 d-man= OK They don't need bottom D
NYI: Not enough for Nelson: Not too far off, Change Fucale by McNiven &amp; it's fair for salary + High Prospect
Nashville: Way too much for a 3rd liner=Allard won't play NHL, it is to please Laval people, so Byron for 2nd &amp; 3rd cond... I prefer to keep Byron!
Winnipeg: I doubt they give up Dano for a 6/7 d-man= Dano played for several team's and at best he is a 3C, switch Benn for Schlemko and it's a deal!
Pittsburgh: Agree= of Course they will need to retain half salary