Joined: Jun. 2017
Posts: 8,697
Likes: 7,071
I like the base of your ideas, at least, but the value could use a little tweaking.
Kapanen for Greenway 1 for 1 is fair IMO. I don't think it's necessary to add the extra picks and Ek to that deal unless we're swapping Ek for one of their D prospects (like Sandlin or Liljegren). Leafs fans won't like that, but realistically I see Sandlin and Liljegren becoming 2nd pairing players at best and Eriksson Eks ceiling is a 2C (but more likely a tweener 2C/3C).
You should be able to get a lot more for Spurgeon, especially if we retain half his salary. If I'm Fenton, I push HARD for Sergachev. Yzerman didn't want to move him, but that doesn't mean Brisebois isn't willing to. Ideally we'd target Serg and Johnson, but we'd have to add more than Spurgeon to make that happen (and we would also have to retain half his salary and take on Callahan). Maybe something like Greenway and Spurgeon for Sergachev, Johnson, and Callahan might work.
As for the Carolina deal, if I'm GM I'm only doing that if there's a conditional 2nd attached to Faulk. The condition would be that we gain their pick if Faulk walks in free agency, otherwise you're just moving Zucker for a rental RD which isn't smart asset management.