Joined: Aug. 2020
Posts: 1,299
Likes: 399
The issue canes fan has isn’t that we overvalue players, the issue is it’s super annoying to see 100 deals of pesce for Anderson every day or 13 for Anderson. Canes fans due value pesce highly, me included, because he is a very good well liked player on a good contract. The canes simply have no reason to trade him unless it is to get a significant upgrade elsewhere.
The offer I gave isnt the worst I have seen but the canes likely would pass. Nylander is a great player and is exactly the kind of player the canes are looking for in the top 6. The issue is that while it upgrades the top 6 wing, it also downgrades 3 other positions. The canes have been looking for a 2c for awhile and trochek is hopefully the answer. If they moved him they have to find a center again. Foegele is a good young player who play a north south game and is a great ok guy. Anderson is an upgrade on Mrazek for sure but I’m not really sure how much. Ultimately the loss of pesce, trochek, foegele just probably isn’t worth Nylander and Anderson to the canes. I understand that the canes get a first as well but I just do not think it makes the canes a better team now