Goalie Trade Comps

Team: 2023-24 New Jersey Devils

Initial Creation Date: May 26, 2023

Published: May 26, 2023

Salary Cap Mode: Basic

I didn't know where else to post this....so made into its own post.

But I have seen a lot of goalie trades that have been wildly optimistic recently. While there are some really good netminders in discussion, I thought it might be useful to list out some historical trades to use as comps. Please use this as resource when building your goalie trade ACGMs.

------

*** NOTE: The trades below are just examples using comps...not recommendations. Just ignore them. Nothing to accept or decline here. And the signings...ignore them. This is just about posting the list. ***

------

Summer Goalie Trades

2022 Vanecek (RFA) -- 2nd, 3rd (with 2nd)
2022 Husso (UFA rights) -- 3rd (7th in Vezina voting)
2021 Kuemper (1 year) -- 2022 1st, cond pick, Timmins (was top-10 in Vezina in 2019, 2020)
2021 Hill (RFA) -- Korenar, 2nd
2021 Fleury (1 year) -- Contract of retiring player
2020 Allen (1 year) -- Two 7ths
2020 Murray (RFA) -- 2nd, Gruden
2019 Reimer (2 years) -- Darling, 6th
2018 Grubauer (RFA) -- 2nd (w/ $5.5m cap space - Orpik)
2017 Raanta (1 year) -- 1st (#7oa), DeAngelo (with Stepan)
2016 Andersen (RFA) -- 1st (#30oa), 2nd
2016 Elliott (1 year) -- 2nd, 3rd (9th in Vezina voting)
2016 Bernier (1 year) -- Conditional pick
2015 Jones (RFA) -- 2016 1st, Kuraly
2015 Lehner (2 years) -- 1st (#21oa) (with Legwand)
2015 Talbot (1 year) -- 2nd, 3rd, 7th (7th in Vezina)
2015 Niemi (UFA rights) -- 7th
2013 Schneider (2 years) -- 1st (#9oa)
2013 Bernier (RFA) -- Scrivens, Frattin, 2nd
2012 Bobrovsky (1 year) -- 2nd, 4th, 4th
2012 Lindback (RFA) -- Caron, 2nd, 2nd, 3rd (with Wilson, 7th)
2011 Varlamov (RFA) -- 2012 1st, 2nd
2011 Bryzgalov (UFA rights) -- 3rd, 3rd
2010 Halak (RFA) -- for a top-25 prospect, top-100 prospect (Lars Eller, Ian Schultz) (10th Vezina)
2008 Chris Mason (UFA rights) -- 4th (was top-10 in Vezina)
2007 Toskala (1 year) -- 1st (#13oa), 2nd, 4th (with Mark Bell)
2007 Vokoun (4 years) -- 2008 1st, 2nd, 2nd (6th in 2006 Vezina)
2007 Toivonen (ELC) -- Soderberg
2007 Fernandez (2 years) -- Kalus, 4th (10th in 2006 Vezina)
2006 Raycroft (RFA) -- Tuukka Rask (2004 Calder winner, 2004 top-5 Vezina)
2006 Cloutier (1 year) -- 2nd, 3rd
2006 Luongo (RFA) -- Bertuzzi, Allen, Auld
2004 Lalime (1 year) - cond 4th (5th in 2003 Vezina)
2003 Hedberg (1 year) -- 2nd
2003 Cechmanek (2 years) -- 2nd (was top-10 in 2001, 2003 Vezina)
2002 Tugnutt (2 years) -- 1st (#20oa) (with 2nd)
2001 Turek (1 year) -- Brathwaite, Tkaczuk, Varlamov, 9th (with 4th) (was Vezina runner-up in 2000)
2001 Hasek (1 year) -- 2002 1st, Kozlov (following Vezina win, 4 of last 5 Vezina's)
2000 Weekes (RFA following year) -- 1st (#5oa), 4th (with 2nd)
1999 Turek (RFA) -- 2nd
1998 Terreri (3 years) -- 2nd
1998 Ranford (1 year) -- 2nd, 3rd
1997 Vernon (2 years) -- Two 2nds (with 5th)
1996 Schwab (RFA) -- Jeff Reese, 2nd, 8th
1995 Joseph (RFA) -- Two 1sts (1996 & 1997) (was top-10 in Vezina in 1993, 1994)
1995 Dafoe (2 years) -- 1996 1st, 4th (with Khristich)
1994 Vernon (1 year) -- Steve Chiasson
1993 Hextall (1 year) -- 1st (#14oa), Fitzpatrick (with 1st (#23oa))
1993 Vanbiesbrouck (1 year) -- Lidster (later taken in expansion draft) (top-10 1992 Vezina)
1992 Burke (RFA rights) -- Holik, 2nd (with Weinrich)
1989 Peeters (2 years) -- 5th (with Acton) (10th in Vezina voting)
1987 Malarchuk (2 years) -- Duchesne, Haworth, 1st (#15oa) (with Dale Hunter) (4th in 1986 Vezina)
1984 Melanson (1 year) -- 1985 1st
1984 Wamsley (4 yr) -- 1st (#8oa), 2nd (with 2nd, 2nd, 3rd)


In-Season or Deadline Goalie Trades

2023 Korpisalo (rental) -- Quick, 1st, 3rd (with Gavrikov)
2022 Fleury (rental) -- 2nd (following 2021 Vezina win)
2020 Lehner (rental) -- Demin, Subban, 2nd (3rd in 2019 Vezina)
2017 Bishop (rental) -- 4th (2016 Vezina runner-up)
2014 Miller (rental) -- Stewart, Carrier, Halak, 1st, 3rd (with Steve Ott)
2014 Berra (RFA at end of year) -- 2nd
2013 Bishop (RFA at end of year) -- Conacher, 4th
2012 Bishop (RFA at end of year) -- 2nd
2011 Anderson (rental) -- Brian Elliott (was 4th in 2010 Vezina)
2010 Giguere (1.5 yrs) -- Toskala, Blake
2010 Toskala (rental) -- Giguere (with Blake)
2010 Toskala (rental) -- Curtis McElhinney
2009 Leclaire (rental) -- Vermette (with 2nd)
2008 Huet (rental) -- 2nd
2006 Roloson (rental) -- 1st, 3rd (extended for 3 yrs after season)
2003 Kiprusoff (RFA at end of year) -- 2nd
2001 Khabibulin (2.5 years) -- Zainullin, Johnson, Mara, 2nd (with Neckar)
1999 Vernon (rental) -- Radek Dvorak (with 3rd) (1997 Conn Smythe)
1998 Snow (1.5 years) -- Sean Burke
1997 Carey (1.5 years) -- Oates, Ranford, Tocchet (with 3rd, Allison, Carter) (following 1996 Vezina win)
1996 Ranford (rental) -- 1st, Brown, Czerkawski
1995 Terreri (rental) -- 2nd
1995 Roy (rental) -- Kovalenko, Rucinsky, Thibault (with Keane) (extended 3yr)
1994 Cheveldae (2 years) -- Bautin, Essensa (with Drake) (7th in 1993 Vezina)
1992 Fuhr (2 years) -- 1993 1st, Andreychuk, Puppa
1992 Tugnutt (??) -- Martin Rucinsky (1991 top-10 Vezina)
1992 Wregget (rental) -- Benning, Recchi, 1st (with Samuelsson, Tocchet, 3rd)
1989 Wregget (3 years) -- Two 1989 1sts
1989 Hrudey (rental) - Crossman, Fitzpatrick, McBean (3rd in 1988 Vezina)
1988 Barrasso (2.5 years) -- Bodger, Shannon (with 4th) (1988 Vezina runner-up)
1988 Moog (rights) -- 2nd, Courtnall, Ranford (was 5th in 1988 Vezina voting)
1987 Jensen (1 year) -- Garry Galley (was top-10 in 1986 Vezina)
1986 Froese (??) -- Kjell Samuelsson, 1989 2nd (1986 Vezana runner-up)

------

*** NOTE: The trades below are just examples using comps...not recommendations. Just ignore them. Nothing to accept or decline here. And the signings...ignore them. This is just about posting the list. ***

------

1.

2.

3.