Big John T
Joined: Sep. 2018
Posts: 468
Likes: 84
I don't even think Zaitsev is overpaid today. He's just on the high end of comparables because he came in as a mature UFA. The contract was fair, the mistake would be not trading him at the point of maximum benefit.
For the Leafs, I don't like him because he is the most overpaid on the team today. If he declines from top-4 quality, he becomes a big overpayment and the Leafs are tied down by term + NTC right at the moment when the cap is squeezing the hardest against the Cup window. It's just happens to be that with Zaitsev we can do something about it and get ahead of the problem.
No one would choose Marleau over Nylander, but we are stuck with Marleau so all eyes are on Nylander instead.
Same thing with wanting to trade Gardiner if we can't afford to keep him. An in-house rental isn't free, it comes at the cost of blocking a younger kid (see Jokiharju in Chicago stealing a spot that was up for grabs)
I'd shut up and be happy if NYI dealt with us, but they're over the moon with their improvement from last year and won't see the need to make any changes.