Quoting: Jangle29
Marner is not worth 4 unprotected 1st round picks. Lou would be fired making that deal. You are the one and only person who believes he is worth that and yet the people who have watched him for 250 games say he is not.
His with/without Tavares stats are dreadful.
He is a winger not a centre.
He doesnt score goals which is the highest paid skill in the NHL
He is only the 8th-12th best winger, so why pay him like the #1
He is not even the best RFA this summer. Point, Rantanen, Laine, Aho, and maybe even Provorov all have more value than Marner to be honest
Actually, just looking around on here, seems A LOT of people are willing to give up for 1sts for someone like Marner, not just me.
To address your RFA comment - Point is the only one who would actually be worthy of an offer sheet. Colorado has PLENTY of CAP space to match any offer for Rantanen, WPG can sign Laine and make it work and Carolina can also match an Aho offer sheet. The Leafs literally can't match an offer sheet over 10 mil per without having to make a TON of moves to free up space and let several other players walk.
And you may be right, Marner may not be WORTH the 4 1sts, but given the Leafs situation, the Islanders biggest need is RW AND the CAP room to make it work I can see Lou making the offer. Isles ownership isn't going to fire him for this, they gave him the reigns to change the culture of the team, this would certainly do that.
Lastly, Marner put up about 70 pts last season without Tavares and he's only 21 years old. Plus it's not like he's going to be playing with a slouch of a center here in NY, he's going to playing alongside last years Calder Trophy winner and a pretty skilled player himself.
What's really laughable in this era of hockey is that Leafs fans think Marner, after a 94 (I believe) point season is going to sign for less than Tavares who has NEVER had a 90 point season.