All values seem to be off, and I don't think their is a fit with Columbus on Nylander. Leafs could get far more going somewhere else solely based on what they got for Kapanen. As for Kerfoot, no way they would give up additional pieces there. In my mind it would be a 1-for-1 hockey deal. No sense moving Holl unless you could find a better per player roster slot value. Savard, even at basically half his salary retained (and I don't like his 1-year left on deal), does not get you a sufficient bump on that analysis to make trading Holl worth it. And TJ Brodie is not a top-pairing defender.

Teams will shut the first line down and this team will never score. I have always been a big Anderson guy, but he looked dreadful this year. At times he was unplayable. You might have just traded a 30+ goal scorer for a forth dman.