I don't really want Dvorak. His 5v5 numbers aren't that great.

I don't know why their is so much love shown for Dvorak by Leaf fans. He may be worth 4.4m contract, but certainly the trade proposed and others are really overpayments by the Leafs.
For some reason many Leaf fans are really enamoured by non playoff teams players.
In what world does the cap work. Tatar and Ritchie sign for 1m?

While they are not superb 5v5 numbers, he would almost certainly increase his 5v5 production playing with elite level players.

But you can add the fact that the Leafs PP could use a shot in the arm and that is a plus as well, and then you can add the fact that he kills penalties as well and you have a 3 format player that could easily meet the production you get from Hyman for less than 5 million per for another 4 year and I think it’s a steal.

You are going to pay to trade for a top 6 player, AZ isn’t going to give him away, and if you consider the alternatives you are getting, I think he is worth giving up a little more. A top 6 winger that could easily put up .5 pts per game playing in the Leafs top 6 is worth a top end prospect and an early round pick plus.