Kidney doesnt have that value to move up that much
Farrell is a dwarf but a good one. Still not enough value, Caufield went 15th OA remember
Roy is a legit one because he is still 18 yo and was the best player in the Q this season

Roy + 26th + one of Farrell or Kidney doesnt move you in the top 10 IMO

Habs are better off keeping Roy / Farrell IMO

Because they are Habs prospects it automatically lowers their value on this sight. You are better of finding similar players on other teams and asking their value to get a fair evaluation of them.



How does Kidney not have significant value, Roy is literally the same age and Kidney finished 7th in QMJHL scoring immediately ahead of Bolduc who is a top prospect for the Blues. It is amazing how one prospect who was drafted in the 5th round is viewed as a better prospect than one drafted in the 2nd round of the same draft and only put up 19 points more. Both Kidney's and Roy's stocks have risen since their draft but fans see Roy as the better prospect because his value has jumped more based on his draft position. Don't get me wrong I am not saying Roy is not the better prospect just that Kidney's value is close to Roy's and Bolduc's.

I’m looking at a lot of different things, Roy is a way better goal scorer, he have a better frame for the NHL, he was good during training camp. Now for Kidney, he is a playmaker, he is 168 pounds, wasn’t good at training camp. Yes his stock has risen, but Roy is a better prospect than Kidney, and guys who can score and have good seize are always more valuable than small playmakers. I really like both, but Roy have better value than Kidney. I’m not saying he will be better tho

I know Roy has more value since he has a bit more "size" (30 lbs heavier) but Kidney can gain that muscle mass with a nutritionists help. I wasn't actually commenting on Roy being more valuable, I was commenting on you saying that Kidney "doesnt have that value to move up that much" and then saying "Roy is a legit one because he is still 18 yo and was the best player in the Q this season". They are the same age and both finished top 10 in league scoring, so while Roy has more value it is not significantly more. Especially considering Kidney is a center and Roy is a winger. I think both could return a late 1st or early 2nd (IMO the difference between the 2 is like to draft spots with Roy being the higher of the 2)