Quoting: BoomerTheHero
and in each of those the teams were given additional compensation to take those contracts on, which indicates they have negative value, just like Kerfoot would.
What additional compensation did the Canucks get for taking Beauvillier? Horvat's value was pegged at a 1st + a prospect, which they got - but they also had to take 2x$4.15M of Beauvillier and retain 25% on Horvat this season with no extra compensation.
What additional compensation did the Blues get for Blais? Tarasenko fully retained & Mikkola brought back a 1st/3rd combo with a longshot prospect in Hunter Skinner. VT's fully retained value was thought to be a 1st, and a mid-round pick has been the going rate for a 3rd pair D. I find it hard to argue that Skinner, a guy who's spent half his year in the ECHL three years after he was drafted, is anything more than a random body thrown in for contract purposes.
Hathaway and Orlov got back a 1/2/3 combo with Craig Smith coming along. Orlov was double retained down, and I don't think you can really argue with him being worth a 1st/3rd at that rate? And if Tanner Jeannot was worth the package that Tampa gave him, I don't think you can argue that Hathway is worth a 2nd rounder three drafts away. Not sure where the compensation for Smith is here, either.
And with the Sharks deal, the Devils didn't give up any of their top prospects and only gave up one guaranteed 1st, while including Johnsson's cap and getting Meier fully retained. I don't see anything in that trade that strikes me as compensation for taking Mongo's $3.4M cap hit off the Devils' hands.
It's a flat cap world, and the teams in the playoff hunt are all mostly capped out. Taking back an expiring cap hit with whatever picks and prospects you're getting is part of doing business right now, and if you're going to pass on a mid-tier prospect and a 3rd rounder for your backup goalie because you demand that you get compensated for taking that cap back, then teams are going to find a different guy to focus on. You adjust to the trade market as it evolves, or you get shut out of it. It's pretty simple.