Quoting: Minnachu
Senators cannot wait a couple of years. Plus neither have great ceilings either way. At least change the 3rd to EDM's 1st. The vast majority of teams will beat this offer easily, even if it's an underwhelming one.
Disagree. The Sens can wait a couple of years for another crop of kids to come. The key components of this team are signed long term (Sanderson being the exception).
If the Sens were to get a 1st in a Cat deal, I would suggest it is more likely a 2024.... which by your argument is worse.
You need to think longer term here. L'Heureux I think is ready when Giroux comes off the books. Prokop is 3 years..... but has that Chris Phillips edge the Sens haven't had since, well, Chris Phillips. But that lines up with Zub or a more movable Chabot. And with Kleven also in the mix, that time frame can be extended to 4.
Maybe you can upgrade Prokop? Possibly. But chose him simply based on ability and where he was drafted. Preds arguably have other prospects "more ready", and given the depth on the RD they have, could possibly be had. (Note: I don't beleive they are as deep as people think, otherwise why sign Livingstone?)
This is a deal that cannot be compartmentalized. It is not about immediate replacements. It does become about extending a win now window beyond 3-5 years.