Quoting: bg77
Hello palhal,
What about trading Nylander in a sign-and-trade is craziness? Dubois, Debrincat, and Horvat are just a few recent examples where this has also taken place. The Flames also extended Huberdeau and Weegar immediately after acquiring them last summer. Calgary is desperate for scoring help and there would be a huge incentive for them to acquire him now so they can get a head start in signing him. They just traded away Tyler Toffoli who was their only 30 goal scorer last season, and there are concerns about other players in the final of their contracts leaving for nothing. They also get the advantage of being able to offer the extra year.
Thank you for proving my point. Your examples aren't even close the Nylander situation.
Now think. Can you think of an example where a CONTENDING Cup team, tells one of star players, who has one year left on his contract ....."We want your ass off this team, so hurry and sign a contract with a team of our choice so we can trade you. And if you can't come to an agreement, you are welcome back to our team for a Cup run.
CONTENDING teams acquire upcoming UFAs all the time, especially at TDL knowing full well they won't be resigning those players.
Dubois and DeBrincat were not under contract as July 1st. they were going to be RFAs, so they had the right to negotiate all teams on July 1st. The Kings and Wings, and those two players made a conditional offer as long as trade could be worked out, without going the league's compensation rules, or the Jets/Sens and bypassing the Jets/Sens being able to match if there were offer sheets
Horvat was on. a non playoff team was going to a UFA in a few months and was traded to team that was trying to make a playoffs playoff team.....that happens all the time, and isn't similar to the situation your Nylander scenario.
The actual trade for Tkachuk was good for both teams. The Flames were under no obligation to sign Huberdeau and Weager. They could have been Flames for a year and left as UFAs or the Flames could have traded them at TDL for futures. Huberdeau looks like the worse contract in the league. 10.5m X 8 for a likely declining winger whose deal starts at 30 years of age.
Calgary, gee they can't make the playoffs last season, with all their upcoming UFA....Lindholm, Backlund, Hanifan, Zaradov, and Toffelli. Makes sense if the Flames don't think they are playoff or certainly Cup contenders to trade those player....Toffelli has already been traded.
The Flames situation compared to the Leafs isn't similar at all.
Leafs have Matthews, Nylander, Bertuzzi, Brodie, Domi all upcoming UFA. By your logic shouldn't the Leafs allow those five upcoming UFAs to negotiate extensions with other teams now.
Yep, Thinking players under contract from contending team being allowed to negotiate a contract with another team, is craziness. Just doesn't happen.