SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

Mac_Attack

Member Since
Apr. 17, 2018
Favourite Team
Toronto Maple Leafs
2nd Favourite Team
Pittsburgh Penguins
Forum Posts
32
Posts per Day
0.0
Forum: Armchair-GMJun. 18, 2018 at 9:11 p.m.
Forum: Armchair-GMJun. 5, 2018 at 7:35 p.m.
Thread: Vegas - Karlsson Trade
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Sens4life</b></div><div>That trade isn't even close to being fair. Try adding Theodore+2020 1st</div></div>

I was thinking of adding the 2020 1st instead of the 2020 2nd so that would make sense but the sens already stated that if a team take bobby Ryans contract int he Karlsson trade then they would take a little less back. Suzuki is a top prospect and then they would be getting two 1sts and a 2nd. Then Lindberg and merril are extras who could possible become something on ottawa cause they would get a chance to play. Its basically SUzuki two 1sts and a 2nd for karlsson then the two other guys for Ryan but to ottawa Ryans value is really low and getting rid of them is important to them. I understand when you look at the names on both sides it looks unfair but you have to also look at the circumstances. The trade that was surfacing during the deadline was very similar to this but i think instead of suzuki it was tuch but there wasnt two 1sts involved and that trade was very close to going through.
Forum: Armchair-GMJun. 4, 2018 at 9:06 p.m.
Thread: I can't Sleep because of this Offer. PLEASE COMMENT
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>jassan28</b></div><div>I am talking about a young Duncan Keith that can staple the Right end of any defence corps. Do you know how many teams are looking in the mirror as they lack the much needed RHD. Oilers have been a basement team for years after lacking a RHD
Did you know that MVP Hart Trophy Left Winger Taylor Hall was traded for a second pairing RHD Adam Larsson.
Watch Jacob Trouba's two way game and the Minutes he plays every game. Kid would have never got traded in my eyes it's only that he doesn't want to play for a Canadian market. Points won't define defenceman, there is a reason teams jump on RHD, ask Toronto how their RHD end looks like. Roslovic played with Auston Matthews and watch his goals. He can be a Trochek type player if developed patiently. Will be up for Calder voting if he hadn't played 29 games</div></div>

You r using the hall for larsson trade in this. Thats how u know ur trade is bad. The hall for larsson trade was a horrible trade, hall being a MVP candidate.
Forum: Armchair-GMJun. 4, 2018 at 8:46 p.m.
Thread: Ekman-Larsson
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>aaron012</b></div><div>"This is so bad?" lol, thanks buddy.</div></div>

He is right. It is so bad.

Why would leafs give up gardiner, lilegren, kapanen and a first for OEL. OEL had 42 points which is good considering the team he played on. But gardiner had 52 points. Both have 1 year left so thats a one for one trade off. OEL obviously has more value than gardiner but not Lilegren, kakpanen and a 1st kind of more value. Lilegren is leafs best prospect could be better than gardiner and OEL kapanen is a top 6 player playing bottom 6 because no room on leafs which they should have this year and hes an amazing penalty killer. and then also a first ontop of all that? The value u just gave up would be for a player like doughty. No way leafs giving all that up especially for another LD.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 20, 2018 at 4:29 p.m.
Thread: Holtby Gone
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>biglite351</b></div><div>I do follow the NHL. Do you? Do you follow Ottawa at all? Like AT ALL? They are not going to retain salary. Period. Holtby retention (as opposed to the Ottawa retention) would be necessary because Ottawa wants less salary, LESS, and they are not going to want to pay nearly $11M for goaltending.

Reading comprehension much? I never said that they would not trade Hoffman, I said that they would not trade him for a position that they do not need. Those are not the same thing, at all. And the certainly wont trade Hoffman for a position that they do not need AND retain salary. They just extended Anderson and are not going to bring in a replacement, even such ELITE ones that you are getting rid of him. If you are going to move Holtby somewhere, make it a team that is actually looking for goaltending. Buffalo for example. Philly. A place that didn't just give their starter a raise in an extension.

What part of your "not a one of them was a defensemen in return" comment has anything to do with Ottawa in rebuild mode? Makes no sense.

Your comment on Holtby "...he makes way more than 2 years"... what? He is signed for 2 years past this one, same as Hoffman. Did you look at any information on the players before posting what your friend said?</div></div>

I do follow the NHL. The Senators, not so much, (they trash) but i still follow any big news from them etc.

And a position they do not need? for a team thats rebuilding im sure a 36 year old goalie is what they need right? When they re-signed anderson obviously its cause they wouldnt expect a Holtby to be available (not saying he is just for this scenario) and if that was the case they wouldnt have re-signed anderson. and yes i made a mistake when looking at holtby contract it is 2 years but that is perfect because andersons new contract is also 2years. Ottawa is not gonna be a playoff team for the next two years they are going to be a developing team. Developing teams have a bunch of cap space spare each season. so for the next two season they will have a lot of cap space to and can afford to have both anderson and holtby and once the two years is over they dont need to sign anderson. If this was last years ottawa senator of course they wouldnt want to trade hoffman and retain salary. but they are not last years ottawa senators. Also u are so big on ottawa not wanting to retain salary when they retained 1.75 mill on phaneufs contract who still has three years left after this year ( like I said i follow big news on senators).

I actually did look at philly and buffalo as teams to trade along with every team in the nhl but buffalo has nothing wsh would want, niether does philly. If wsh was going to trade Holtby its obviously to aquire another star/depth other wise why trade him. Buffalo has no star that would really make sense for them to trade and philly stars r expensive and long term.

Once again I wouldnt trade Holtby but if he were to get traded this makes a lot of sense. The fact u think a 36 year old goalie is ottawa's future goalie is a joke. He had terrible stats this year and is only going to get better. And hes 36 hes most likely going to retire soon. Then what does ottawa do for a goalie? U say a position they dont need well clearly ur not looking into the future. They have filip gustavsson that pens traded to sens but hes still only 19 he wont be ready soon and theres not guarentee he will be great either where as with Holtby ur guarenteed a starting/elite goalie for years to come.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 20, 2018 at 4:01 p.m.
Thread: Holtby Gone
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Eli</b></div><div>They like their goalies. I have heard nothing but good things about them. So I assume they need to shore up the defense to get full value out of any goalie.

You're talking about playoff scoring depth and trading for Hoffman based one a point every other game in the palyoffs, as a 26 and 27 year old.

Most goal scorers (like Hoffman and Smith-Pelly) peak at age 27. They improve up to about that point, and they get a little worse each year after that. Hoffman at 28 is likely just over the hill to where he'll have to start training like Chara if he wants to maintain his current scoring pace. Smith-Pelly, in a small sample size this Spring, is as good as Hoffman, at less than a 6th of the cap hit. And he's three years younger, still trending upward. I wouldn't trade them straight up.

Holtby has the 2nd all time playoff save percentage, and is doing well against Columbus where Grubauer didn't. He's a big game player and the Caps need him to get any further than they have, or they need to get an even better superstar back to make up for losing him. Hoffman makes up for losing Smith-Pelly, this year, but next year he'll be a little worse. Condon doesn't make up for losing Holtby, yet, so the Caps have lost this trade on the ice.

You've also invested all available cap space in a fourth line center you have to buy out right away because he was -32 with 5 goals this year. Please try again?</div></div>

In regards to the fourth line center hes -32 cause hes on an ass team. put him on a good team and he will produce. look at last year when ottawa was good and made it all the way to the est finals. He had 32 points and was a plus 6. This year he played on one of the worst teams in the NHL. Wsh is one of the best teams in the nhl.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 20, 2018 at 1:54 p.m.
Thread: Holtby Gone
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>biglite351</b></div><div>Your over overvaluation of Caps player's worth never ceases to amaze me. It's almost like the old "All of our worst players for all of your best players" but you don't even realize it because you actually think that they are that good. Are there any players on that roster that you don't think are stars?

DSP is an NHLer, that is for sure, but that's about all that you can say about him. If DSP is "the trade" then it is for a 4th or 5th round pick. He is a 25 year old on his 4th NHL team for a reason. He was bought out by New Jersey for a reason. He is currently on his lowest salary contract ever for a reason. None of those are because he is a "the trade" level of player.

Hoffman would make every team better if he went to it.
Holtby would make every team better if he went to it. However, many teams already have a starting goalie so they simply would not pay the trade price for him.</div></div>

You say "all our worst players for your all your best" but holtby is the best player in the whole trade. and then u say many teams already have a starting goalie well im not trading to many teams, im trading to ottawa who has anderson who hasnt been great, is getting old and ottawa is trying to rebuild. DSP wasnt supposed to be the guy that ottawa gets back for hoffman i just threw him in there cause capitals were over cap space and even if dsp hasnt doen much yet he is still young and thats what ottawa wants. U guys talk like hoffman name hasnt already come up in trade talks this season. his name was at the top for players available at the deadline along with karlsson. Ottawa had that team and finished bottom 5 in the league this season. Hence the reason they are trying to rebuild. And no team is ever going to win a cup in this age with out a star goalie and Holtby is just that. And also im not even a wsh fan so im not even biased on holtby. Im a pens fan so i hate the caps.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 20, 2018 at 1:46 p.m.
Thread: Holtby Gone
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Eli</b></div><div>Yep. It's a doublenope. Neither team is improved by this deal and each loses someone they really don't want to lose.

DSP has 10 points in 28 career playoff games, though, including two in four this year at 25 (the other opportunities were at 23 and under). Mike Hoffman is a point every other playoff game kinda winger, based on playoff games only at ages 26 and 27. Now he's 28. Smith-Pelly in a small sample size is a point every other playoff game winger at 25, and might keep improving next year and the year after that.

So he's not a throw in for Hoffman. He's the trade.

Bye.</div></div>

Ottawa was already trying to trade hoffman at the deadline so its not like ottawa doesnt want to trade him. DSP hasnt been great but hes young which is what ottawa is looking for. you said each team loses but they dont. Ottawa gets an Elite goalie for their future and wsh gets depth which is the reason why every year they cant make it past the second round in the playoffs cause they have no depth right now. Ottawa getting holtby is a huge head start on their rebuild because no matter how many young start forward u have ur not gonna win if u dont have that great goalie. look at buffalo for example they have so many young stars yet still finished last in the nhl cause they dont have that elite goalie.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 20, 2018 at 1:39 p.m.
Thread: Holtby Gone
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>biglite351</b></div><div>No way that Ottawa trade happens, at all. Hoffman is one of their key players. No way that they trade him for a position that they do not really need (starting goalie). No way that they retain salary, pretty much period (they are more interested in cutting salary as opposed to retaining). Smith-Pelly is a dime-a-dozen RFA, no need to trade for him as there will be 20 of him available 7/1.

Remove the Hoffman retained salary and add 50% retained on Holtby and Ottawa might not hang up right away.</div></div>

Wow, first off do you even follow the nhl? Ottawa is trying to rebuild. Hoffman was already being talked about being traded at this years deadline. Even Karlsson was close to being traded. Ottawa does need a ELITE goalie, Holtby is more than just a starter. Anderson is not good enough and is getting old. for a team trying to rebuild thats not ur goalie of the future. I retained hoffman contract because he only has 2 years left and because ottawa is rebuilding they are going to have a lot of cap left over for the next few years. Why would i retain holtby contract he makes 6 mill which is not even a lot for an ELITE goalie and he makes way more than 2 years. Ottawa was trying to trade Karlsson at the draft for prospects to help in the future and picks which none of them were a defence man in return so the facct u think ottawa would hang up the phone when they have a chance of getting a head start on that rebuild is beyond me. And just to clear it up if i was wsh i wouldnt trade holtby but my friend says is wsh doesnt win the cup this year they should make a big move in trading holtby so i decided to do this.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 20, 2018 at 1:30 p.m.
Thread: Holtby Gone
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>Eli</b></div><div>Starting 60 games in Hershey and winning the Calder Cup.

But is Condon's slightly greater experience worth the extra 2M cap hit over Copley? No. This build seems to think Holtby is getting the axe after four straight 30 win seasons, or that Washington needs a left wing. I'm not sure which is more ridiculous.</div></div>

I got condon just as a backup because based off this year when Holtby did bad Grubauer came in and helped out with great stats. I would want the same for when grubauer does bad and copley hasnt done well enough to be in the nhl. But that doesnt mean he wont during the season and if he does wsh can just flip Condon to another team for a pick.

I personally wouldn't trade Holtby I have the same arguement as you that Holtby hasn't been wsh problems but my friend thinks if wsh doesnt win the cup this year they should make a big move in trading holtby so i decided to make the most possible trade. Ottawa is a team that needs a starting goalie forsure and they also were going to trade hoffman at this years deadline. Wsh doesnt need a lw but they certainly need depth and by adding hoffman thats what they are getting.
Forum: Armchair-GMApr. 17, 2018 at 1:08 p.m.
Thread: WSH with depth
<a href="/users/Capsule" target="_blank">@Capsule</a> I looked around at what teams would need a starting goalie that's somewhat young and Vancouver was the best bet because they will start their rebuild now that the Sedin's retired. Markstrom isn't a starter so they could use him definitely and I decided to take Nilsson to be Wsh backup. Gagner makes sense because Wsh needs depth and depth scoring and Beagle wasn't even that good this year. Gagner was way better and was on Vancouver. The good thing about Gagner is i got them to retain cap so we have him for 2 years really cheap and he can be moved around the roster. if the team needs scoring he can play top 6 because hes had 30-50 point seasons his whole career. I could've maybe got a higher pick then a 5th though.

Trading Orpik does cost the Caps anything, it helps them because hes playing top 6 on wsh and is a minus 9 with only 10 points. He hasn't been helping them in anyway, Getting rid of his cap means Wsh can add more depth which they desperately need.

I do agree maybe I could've found someone better than Chaisson but he was pretty solid for a fourth liner this year he was a plus 1 with 18 points in 67 games. He will get more with Gagner on his line who can get offense going.

Thanks for the feedback!