Isles add 2 needs

holy crap no way islanders do this. Take out 13OA and add a 2nd. Neither of those guys combined are worth close to this

Don't see why Washington adds a 2nd here. Washington is giving up the younger goalie with potential for a 34 year old goalie with a .003 better save percentage. If anything, I'd think the Isles add something minor, like a 5th or something around there instead of Washington adding a 2nd.

If anything the Isles r getting too little. I don’t think Vanecek has much room to grow. Also the difference in save percentage can be explained away by the quality of team in front of the two net minders.

I wouldn’t even want either player tbh

So we should value players like Tokarski more because he can win playoff games? If you think a 34 year old goalie with a .911 sv% should get more than a 2nd rounder and a 26 year old goalie with a .908 sv% , I think you should reconsider your values. Just because he won a couple playoff rounds could just as easily be a reflection on the team in front of him, and it's not worth as much as you think.