LOL WHAT, yes McD is expensive, but not godly. You're trying to make him value the same as karlsson. Stop this

Just no. This is crazy. Maybe in a video game. Even then I think the computer would say no to all three of these trades. The Rangers would love to get Robby Fabbri straight up for Rick Nash but St Louis isn't stupid. Also three top prospects and 2 picks for McD? not a chance

Oh dear..

Yeah thats not gonna happen

Fan proposals are similar to deals made 5-15 years ago before GMs realized how much damage they were doing to their teams.
In no current world is Nylander included in a deal for McD and the reality is that if the price started with Dermott, it would be a quick conversation.

I like what Yzerman said the other day, he'll add but not at the cost of young roster players. Picks. Sure. Prospects that aren't playing in the NHL, sure. But not these pipedream proposals where the selling team gets whatever they want.

The Leafs would be noticeably worse if they made a deal as bad as the one proposed above.

Not only is a silly proposal for McDonagh, fact is not other team would even offer 25% of that for McDonagh. So in any trade, if a team really wants to move a player, there is limited amount of suitors and most trade offers will be somewhat equal in value. Looks like Rangers will continue to employ McDonagh for next 1.5 years and then they resign as UFA. Then they there big three will be McDonagh, Staal and Shattenkirk in 2019. Real progress.