Quoting: Jake_H
Holtby, Andersen, Lundqvist, Crawford, and Quick all settled into the NHL at 23 or later. Murray and Fleury are extreme exceptions, and the vast majority of goalies don't stick till their mid twenties. Jarry playing the first few months of the season in the AHL to prove himself is nothing out of the ordinary.
in case you missed it the NHL finally caught the boat a few years ago. The average age of a player in the NHL is dropping fast.
The reason for this is because almost every study in existence shows that you hit your physical peek in your mid 20s and it's all down hill from there. As the NHL is evolving from some bush league sport to a real sport it has got the message. You are looking at Jarry entering into his physical peek. The only excuses at this point are if a goalie gets a late start. But you can't say that about Jarry. He's been playing for 9 years. If you haven't figured out how to play the position after 9 years you are done. He's played hundreds of games, you either have it or you don't.
10 years ago I may have agreed with you. But it's not 10 years ago. He's at the range now where his reflexes and his flexibility will never be greater. As he gets into his upper 20s and 30s he will start to slow and become less flexible. That's not a knock on him that called nature. Every athlete fights it they all lose. While they can still be a good player, even they know it's not the same as when they were in their mid 20s.
So there is no point hiding him down there to play 10 more games a year, while playing a guy you know is not it, in DeSmith. If anything it stunts his growth. He's better off practicing and playing 30 games a year and getting coaching at the NHL level than he is sitting in the AHL. Playing against players like Sesttito and McKegg aren't going to make you a better player. It's a faster game in the NHL, and if you are to hit the next step it's time to get use to it., Not rot away in your athletic peek playing with slower players.