Columbus stated that they want a return of a good top six forward and an elite prospect (Henrik Borgstrom caliber). But I think that it would be a great place for him to play in Nashville.

Panarin, an extension and not giving up a first? Would suck to lose Fiala but I'll take Panarin for that anytime.

i like it but if your not giving up a first take out a second and that sc thing put in tolvenen si its panarin for a second fiala and tolvenen

if panarin signs an extension as part of the trade youd have to give up way more than that...

Yes but that doesn’t happen... panarin can only be traded for the value that Columbus owns. That is till July 1st. He is a rental that Nashville could sign, but hey they could also just sign him in July and give Columbus nothing. Would be smart for Columbus to take this deal.

it literally says in the trade details that "Panarin signs 9m×8years contract"

He can type whatever he wants in the details... they can add a flying unicorn too but I like to deal in reality. panarin his agent have already stated they will not discuss contracts in season.

How many sign and trades were posted for Karlsson and Pacioretty... my point is they don’t happen.

ok cool... i never said it was realistic, but in this armchair gm panarin did sign an extension...

in my original comment i said:

"if panarin signs an extension as part of the trade youd have to give up way more than that..."

key word: IF

If you check out my original post I said Yes.... but that doesn’t happen

I never said that a sign and trade would happen. I even agree with you that they are uncommon. All I said is that in this armchair gm (a scenario where a sign and trade did happen) panarin is worth more than fiala + two 2nds

And that’s why I said yes, but the reality is that they do not happen. He will either be kept for playoffs and maybe they try to resign him or he will be dealt at TDL as a rental.