Quoting: Matthew7
So with that being said I do not trust advanced analytics that much and that is that.
This is the equivalent of saying that I don't trust goal totals or Assists. Underlying metrics, rather than counting results, count good play.
As an example, a player starts in his own end and rushes with the puck. He enters the Ozone and does a loop of the offensive zone looking for a good play. He then passes the puck to the Dman, who goes D-to-D, who then takes a shot which is tipped in by the guy in front.
I'd just like to add that I literally described William Nylander here
The player who did all the work gets no recognition for the play using 'normal' stats, but the advanced stats would be lighting up like a Christmas tree across the board (corsi, zone entries and exits etc).
What people who don't understand adv stats dont realize, is that adv stats are the numerical compilation OF the eye test. I just want to say that one more time: They ARE the eye test, but crudely put into numbers. That is not to say you should only go based on the numbers, but to discount them entirely is to discount the thousands of things that happen on the ice every second that a person cant see because they only have two eyes. Its beyond stupid and regressive and ultimately hurtful to your own cause.