I never wanted Mantha just contradicted Detroit fans claiming Mantha is some how more valuable than Domi. I have never made an ACGM involving Mantha and never will cause IMO he is not what this team needs. We need a healthy top 6 winger capable of scoring 25+ goals a year with size and skill. Otherwise NOT Mantha.

Habs not trading Romanov eithet

I never said anything about Juulsen....good straw man argument though. Juulsen has very little value probably because he's a very average NHL defenseman....

Mantha is not injury prone - that is a fact, my friend.

OK on both accounts Juulsen was projected to be a top 4 D man before the injury and if he truly is fully recovered could still hit that potential. Explain how missing 2 full years out of a 5 year career is not injury prone. Fluke injuries or not he has had multiple injuries over 5 years hence injury prone.

I couldn't care less what he was projected to be, he is CLEARLY not that. Most organization can replace someone of Juulsen's ability for late picks or with someone already in the org.

The comparison in the first place is ridiculous - there is no projection with Mantha. He is a bonafide top line power forward in the NHL.

Take a look at his injuries and how they occurred, then you'll have your answer.

GOOD FOR YOU.

Again I was not comparing Mantha to Juulsen just their injury history. It doesn't matter how the injuries occur. The very definition of injury prone according to the Webster's dictionary is - frequently injured. By that definition Mantha is indeed injury prone whether you want to believe it or not!. I get that your mad that I pointed out his injury history as being another reason to not want Mantha but there is no denying that he has been frequently injured in his first 5 years in the league to the tune of 170 games = 2 full seasons + 7 games out of 5 seasons, that's not great.

So why do Habs fans keep wanting to swap the two...you'd think they'd be over the moon to have the "superior" Domi.

He’s better at C and Habs gave 4 C spots locked up now without him, and they need wingers

Ok, But Habs fans are forgetting Detroit has needs everywhere. If they trade Mantha for a center suddenly they need another winger on the top line and they have a center in Domi but no good wingers for him to play with. A one for one swap would never happen for Detroit, it improves them in no way whatsoever. If Montreal wanted Mantha they need to really make it worth while for Detroit. Otherwise it's steady as she goes in the Red Wing Land with the rebuild. Draft and Develop. Trade when a desperate GM comes along and can be fleeced for picks and prospects.