It would be a crime to get McDavid and Matthews on one team and not play them together, especially when you have quality players to play in the bottom 9

Haha no from Toronto in the trades. Chara will probably retire so why pay him 1mil?

Oilers say no. Mcdavid obviously much better than marner plus I’d rather have Neal than have That extra bunch.

It's not even about the value here. McDavid is your franchise cornerstone, you don't trade that unless you're heading down, which is not the Oilers' case at all

Lol. U should be suspended from the site for a Marner and Kerfott and draft pick for McDavid trade. This is just crazy!! It would Cost Toronto 4 future 1st round pick with Marner and Kerfoot.

I thought this was gonna be a Marner for Puljujarvi trade. That’s why I clicked.

TOR now has McDavid, Tavares, Matthews. so who is C1, who is C2 and who do you demote to the 3rd line? c'mon this is not a well thought out scenario

actually, if you compare their primary assists, Marner is actually first since entering the league, the value isn't necessarily too cra-

just kidding, this trade is balls to the wall ridiculous, stop this immediately, the only way McDavid leaves edmonton is if he walks as a UFA

I'm typically arguing against Oiler fans but this trade is so bad I have to join their cause. WHAT HAVE YOU DONE!

Why are you trading for Gaborik, you don't have any RFA's left??

Ottawa doesn't want Neal. Yes he's still somewhat productive, but he's 33 years old and signed for three more seasons. He doesn't fit in a rebuilding team, and please don't say leadership.

Yeah it’s brutal for Edmonton, and you play Mcdavid on the second line, come on.