Quoting: jnorrrr
This is all over the place man. VGK trade is lopsided in value, that pick should be going the other way. There’s not a chance Subban brings back a 1st. Don’t think NJ should be adding picks onto selling trades like the Palms deal. SJ deal is very hefty and I personally don’t think Meier is worth it. Also, Crawford?
I see where you're coming from and like I said in the description this isn't super realistic its very armchair gmish all over the place. But Ill give you my thought process in response to the criticisms.
VGK trade isn't about player for player. It is about Vegas not being able to get under the cap ceiling with their current situation. Before this season some legit hockey analysts were reporting VGK was shopping Pacioretty at a low value. Possibly even attatching a pick to get a team to eat the full contract. I think that is a bit extreme but it is an example of how they need to move him at a lower cost. In this deal they trade him for a player who plays the same position, is 7 years younger, leads his (bad) team in goals, is a tough playoff type player and (most importantly) would cost 6M less against the cap with retention. I don't see VGK getting a much better deal for a cap dump than that tbh.
Subban is not worth a 1st you're right. But theres a lot more to that deal than just Subban=1st round pick. He is retained at 50% which is a lot for a team sending a player away to take on. And Kulikov (also retained) has legitimately been the most reliable Devils defenseman and has ties to Florida. This may be the Panthers best chance to go for it with the way their team is playing and the weird divisional playoff format. This is giving them a very solid entire 2nd pairing which they need. If they finish high and that 1st rounder is picks 20-32 I think its a wortwhile investment.
See where you're coming from on Palmieri deal I just think it is balancing value to get a 1st rounder kind of like the Goodrow trade a couple years ago for SJS. Personally I'd be willing to give up a 2nd to get a 1st but if you'd rather get a flat 2nd or a 2nd and 3rd or something I wont argue that.
Meier deal: yeah that one is a bit all over the place. I like Meier but might be overvaluing. No argument there.
And you caught my Crawford addition lol. Did that 90% joking. Theres a small part of me that wonders if he might get the itch and finish what he started in NJ since his retirement is apparently not injury related. But that is totally his business and I just added him to see if anyone would notice haha.